• Used car prices have increased 16.8%, or $3,926, over the past 12 months, compared to most years when they remain constant
  • Pickup trucks and sports cars had the highest price increases, which makes them the worst vehicles to buy and the best vehicles to sell
  • Best used vehicles to buy right now only saw minor price bumps including some small SUVs, hatchbacks, and minivans
  • Tesla’s Model S is the only used vehicle that has decreased in price 
 

The global microchip shortage is restricting new car supply, which leads to restricted used car supply due to fewer people trading in their used cars. This combination of diminished supply and increased demand has caused used car prices to soar.

According to iSeeCars.com’s latest analysis of over 1.2 million used car sales in April 2021, used car prices increased 16.8 percent, or $3,926, compared to the same period the previous year. Used car prices typically remain relatively constant year over year, as 2019 had a 0.2 percent reduction over 2018, and 2020 had a 0.1 percent increase over 2019. 

“The current used car price increase is unparalleled, and prices will likely remain elevated for the foreseeable future due to the magnitude of the global microchip shortage and restricted new car supply,” said iSeeCars Executive Analyst, Karl Brauer. “We’ve identified the used cars with the greatest price increases, which can represent lucrative trade-in opportunities for their owners.”

Although the average used car has significantly increased in price, iSeeCars’s analysis also found that some vehicles defied the trend by either decreasing in price or by only slightly increasing. “While used car deals are hard to find, they are still out there, or at the very least, there are used car models that won’t come with as much sticker shock as the average vehicle,” said Brauer.

Top 10 Used Cars With the Greatest Price Increases 

The top ten vehicles with the greatest price increases range from 1.5 to 2.0 times the average vehicle’s price increase, and are primarily pickup trucks, sports cars, and luxury cars. “These used vehicles have proven to be appreciating assets over the past year -- a circumstance not typically associated with used cars,” said Brauer. “Shoppers interested in these vehicles should consider holding off on purchasing them, while consumers who have these vehicles in their garage and are willing to part with them can take advantage of these significantly higher trade-in values.”
Top 10 Cars with the Greatest Price Increases (YoY) - iSeeCars April 2021 Study
Rank Used Vehicle Average Used Car Price (April 2021) $ Price Change from April 2020  Year-Over-Year % Price Change
1 Chevrolet Corvette $68,804 $17,432 33.9%
2 Mercedes-Benz G-Class $148,937 $37,161 33.2%
3 Ram 1500 $35,798 $8,002 28.8%
4 GMC Sierra 1500 $42,347 $9,418 28.6%
5 Mercedes-Benz S-Class $74,326 $16,198 27.9%
6 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 $37,324 $7,960 27.1%
7 Chevrolet Camaro $31,220 $6,582 26.7%
8 Toyota Tundra $40,470 $8,356 26.0%
9 Mitsubishi Mirage $11,242 $2,313 25.9%
10 Land Rover Range Rover Sport $59,579 $11,969 25.1%
Average $27,297 $3,926 16.8%
The vehicle that has the greatest price increase is the Chevrolet Corvette, which has risen in price by 33.9 percent since April 2020. It is joined by another American classic sports car, the Chevrolet Camaro, in seventh. “These sports cars are aspirational cars for many consumers, and they surged in popularity during the pandemic as drivers sought fun cars to combat boredom,” said Brauer. “Sports cars aren’t practical purchases, so drivers are likely more willing to pay a premium for them, especially because they aren’t as common in the used car marketplace.”

Four pickup trucks make the list including the third-ranked Ram Pickup, the fourth-ranked GMC Sierra 1500, the sixth-ranked Chevrolet Silverado 1500, and the eighth-ranked Toyota Tundra. “The shortage of new truck inventory in the wake of the microchip shortage and the growing popularity of pickups has led to heightened demand and scarce supply in the used car marketplace,” said Brauer. “Additionally, people who require trucks for work are more likely to pay a higher price.”’

Three luxury vehicles make the list, including the second-ranked Mercedes-Benz G-Class offroad SUV, the fifth-ranked Mercedes-Benz S-Class sedan, and the tenth-ranked Land Rover Range Rover Sport SUV. “The Mercedes-Benz G-Class is an iconic luxury off-roader that is associated with opulence, the Mercedes-Benz S-Class sedan is among the most luxurious sedans in its class, and the Land Rover Range Rover Sport is an premium and highly-capable off-road SUV, ” said Brauer. “These vehicles embody luxury and are in high demand, likely because buyers have additional resources to spend on cars due to decreased travel and entertainment during the pandemic.”

Rounding out the list on the other end of the price spectrum is the ninth-ranked Mitsubishi Mirage, with an average used car price of $11,242. “The Mitsubishi Mirage’s main appeal is its low price point, making it attainable for new drivers and those looking for cheap transportation,” said Brauer. “The average mileage of Mirages sold in 2021 was also 23 percent lower than in 2020, and this lower mileage likely contributed to increased pricing.”

Top 10 Used Cars With the Smallest Price Changes 

The top ten vehicles with the smallest price differences range from a 2 percent decrease to a 7.6 percent increase and include a mix of vehicle types. “Consumers who are in the market for a used car should consider these vehicles, which include a mix of vehicle types and price points, because they have not been significantly impacted by price hikes,” said Brauer. 
Top 10 Used Cars with the Smallest Price Changes (YoY) - iSeeCars Study
Rank Used Vehicle Average Used Car Price (April 2021) $ Price Change from April 2020 Year-Over-Year % Price Change
1 Tesla Model S $53,212 -$1,077 -2.0%
2 BMW i3 $20,868 $91 0.4%
3 Subaru Crosstrek $22,440 $314 1.4%
4 Mercedes-Benz GLC $35,393 $709 2.0%
5 Audi Q7 $40,626 $1,220 3.1%
6 Toyota Prius $19,087 $971 5.4%
7 Volvo XC90 $39,641 $2,064 5.5%
8 Mazda CX-3 $17,950 $1,062 6.3%
9 Honda HR-V $18,669 $1,203 6.9%
10 Subaru Impreza $18,003 $1,272 7.6%
Average $27,297 $3,926 16.8%
The Tesla Model S is the only used vehicle that has decreased in price in April 2021 compared to April 2020, with a 2.0 percent price decrease amounting to $1,077. “The once high-demand Tesla Model S has declined in popularity thanks to more affordable Tesla models like the Model 3 and Model Y, both of which are substantially cheaper than the used Model S, even when purchased new,” said Brauer. 

Two hybrid vehicles make the list including the second-ranked BMW i3 and the sixth-ranked Toyota Prius. “The BMW i3 plug-in hybrid blazed a trail for plug-in hybrids, but has declined in popularity as more options with more cargo space and better range entered the market,” said Brauer. “Similarly, the popularity of the Toyota Prius put hybrid vehicles on the map, but the Prius has also declined in popularity due to increased competition and a decreasing fuel efficiency advantage over similar models.”

Three subcompact SUVs make the list including the third-ranked Subaru Crosstrek, the eighth-ranked Mazda CX-3, and the ninth-ranked Honda HR-V. “These subcompact SUVs are among the best vehicles in their class, providing affordable options for consumers who want a reliable vehicle,” said Brauer. “Luxurious and larger SUVs are the most in-demand used vehicles right now, meaning these less popular vehicles haven’t had the same price hikes.” 

Three luxury SUVs make the list including the fourth-ranked compact Mercedes-Benz GLC, the fifth-ranked midsize Audi Q7, and the seventh-ranked midsize Volvo XC90. “The Mercedes-Benz GLC and the Audi Q7 are among the highest-rated vehicles in their classes, but they are also among the most expensive, which could explain why their price increases are lower than competitive models,” said Brauer. “The Volvo XC90 is another quality vehicle with advanced technology, but its aging design doesn’t stand out in the competitive luxury midsize SUV segment.”

Rounding out the list is the tenth-ranked Subaru Impreza compact car. “With standard all-wheel drive, the Subaru Impreza offers an affordable option for consumers who want an all-weather vehicle,” said Brauer.

Used Car Price Changes By Body Type

iSeeCars compared used car pricing by body type against the overall average of 16.8 percent.
Used Car Price Changes in April 2021 Compared to Last Year, by Bodystyle - iSeeCars Study
Bodystyle % Change from Last Year Average $ Increase
Pickup 25.3% $7,383
Convertible 25.1% $6,038
Coupe 22.2% $6,673
Sedan 19.9% $3,509
Wagon 19.5% $2,661
Overall Average 16.8% $3,926
Minivan 15.3% $3,539
SUV 14.4% $3,487
Hatchback 12.3% $1,954
Every vehicle segment increased in price compared to last year, while pickup trucks increased the most, followed closely by convertibles and coupes. “The shortage of new pickup trucks has forced buyers to buy used versions, and many buyers are willing to pay a premium because they need trucks for work purposes,” said Brauer. “Demand for sporty convertibles and coupes outpaces what’s available in the used car marketplace, and dealers don’t have to be competitive with pricing because buyers of these kinds of cars may not be as bargain-conscious.”

Minivans, SUVs, and hatchbacks increased in price, but at a rate that is below the 16.8 percent average. “Minivans have declined in popularity, which could contribute to their lower-than-average price increases,” said Brauer. “While large SUVs and many luxury SUVs are in high-demand, lower-priced small SUVs aren’t rising in price, which contributes to the lower-than-average price increase for the entire segment. As for hatchbacks, consumers who want the extra cargo space offered by this body style are likely choosing SUVs instead.”

Used Car Price Increases by City

iSeeCars looked at the top 50 most populous metro areas to see which metro areas had the smallest and largest increase in used car prices in April 2021 compared to April 2020.
Average Used Car Price Increases by City
Rank City Year-Over-Year % Price Change Year-Over-Year $ Price Change
1 Milwaukee, WI 10.6% $2,526
2 New York, NY 10.9% $2,566
3 Austin, TX 12.6% $2,981
4 Minneapolis-St. Paul, MN 12.7% $3,040
5 Oklahoma City, OK 13.5% $3,294
6 Norfolk-Portsmouth-Newport News,VA 14.2% $3,074
7 Houston, TX 14.6% $3,579
8 Chicago, IL 14.7% $3,470
9 Denver, CO 14.7% $3,577
10 Boston, MA-Manchester, NH 14.8% $3,385
11 Hartford & New Haven, CT 14.8% $3,071
12 Indianapolis, IN 14.8% $3,356
13 Albuquerque-Santa Fe, NM 15.2% $3,622
14 Grand Rapids-Kalamazoo, MI 15.4% $3,594
15 Greenville-Spartanburg, SC 15.5% $3,609
16 Kansas City, MO 15.9% $3,782
17 Miami-Ft. Lauderdale, FL 15.9% $3,514
18 San Antonio, TX 16.4% $3,852
19 Greensboro-Winston Salem, NC 16.6% $3,712
20 Raleigh-Durham (Fayetteville), NC 17.0% $3,859
21 Dallas-Ft. Worth, TX 17.2% $4,155
22 Harrisburg-Lancaster-York, PA 17.2% $3,918
23 Philadelphia, PA 17.2% $3,770
24 San Francisco-Oakland-San Jose, CA 17.4% $3,960
25 Los Angeles, CA 17.7% $4,045
26 Charlotte, NC 17.9% $3,984
27 St. Louis, MO 18.0% $4,245
28 West Palm Beach-Ft. Pierce, FL 18.2% $3,859
29 Baltimore, MD 18.3% $3,820
30 Cincinnati, OH 18.3% $3,737
31 Washington, DC (Hagerstown, MD) 19.0% $4,232
32 Cleveland-Akron (Canton), OH 19.3% $3,904
33 Portland, OR 19.5% $4,558
34 Orlando-Daytona Beach, FL 19.6% $4,165
35 Seattle-Tacoma, WA 19.7% $4,698
36 Tampa-St Petersburg (Sarasota), FL 19.8% $4,342
37 San Diego, CA 20.1% $4,298
38 Phoenix, AZ 20.3% $4,571
39 Birmingham, AL 20.5% $4,641
40 Detroit, MI 20.8% $4,482
41 Salt Lake City, UT 20.9% $4,693
42 Memphis, TN 21.0% $4,537
43 Nashville, TN 21.0% $4,849
44 Fresno-Visalia, CA 21.1% $4,318
45 Columbus, OH 21.5% $4,306
46 Pittsburgh, PA 22.4% $4,617
47 Sacramento-Stockton-Modesto, CA 22.7% $5,086
48 Atlanta, GA 22.8% $5,181
49 Jacksonville, FL 23.5% $5,013
50 Las Vegas, NV 25.2% $5,174
Milwaukee had the smallest price increase at 10.6 percent, while Las Vegas had the greatest used car price increase at 25.2 percent.

“The current state of the used car market presents a selling or trade-in opportunity for consumers who may have one of the most in-demand pickup trucks or luxury SUVs,” said Brauer. “Also, the used car market may seem doom and gloom for potential buyers, but consumers should remember that there are still quality vehicles available that haven’t significantly risen in price.”

Methodology

iSeeCars.com analyzed over 800,000 used car sales from model years 2016 to 2020 in April 2021, and over 400,000 used car sales from model years 2015 to 2019 in April 2020. The average listing prices of each car model were compared between the two time periods, and the differences were expressed as both a percentage difference from the 2020 price as well as a dollar difference. Heavy-duty vehicles,low-volume vehicles, vehicles discontinued as of the 2021 model year, and vehicles with fewer than 4 of the 5 model years for each period were excluded from further analysis.

About iSeeCars.com

iSeeCars.com is a car search engine that helps shoppers find the best car deals by providing key insights and valuable resources, like the iSeeCars free VIN check reports. iSeeCars.com has saved users over $284 million so far by applying big data analytics powered by over 25 billion (and growing) data points and using proprietary algorithms to objectively analyze, score and rank millions of new cars and used cars.