Honda vs. Tesla
iSeeCars' unbiased and data-driven comparison of cars from Honda and Tesla contrasts the two brands across a broad spectrum of vehicle specifications to determine which one is better. In addition to comparing pricing and specs, iSeeCars uses all the ratings, rankings, and insights from its comprehensive analyses of vehicle models, including calculations of reliability, safety, depreciation, value retention, and projected lifetime recalls based on recall history. This in-depth evaluation is used to identify which brand represents a better overall choice for shoppers who are considering both Honda and Tesla cars.
When comparing the Honda brand to the Tesla brand, Honda has the advantage in the areas of used car pricing, depreciation, overall quality, reliability, retained value and variety of models offered. Tesla has the advantage in the areas of horsepower, towing capacity and safety.
Honda versus Tesla: Pricing and Value: Honda has a lower used vehicle starting price in 2 out of 2 comparisons. Honda models depreciate at a lower (better) rate in 3 out of 3 comparisons. The lower overall prices for Honda, plus their lower depreciation rate, gives Honda the overall advantage over Tesla.
Honda versus Tesla: Horsepower, Fuel Efficiency and Towing Capacity: Tesla vehicles offer higher maximum horsepower numbers in their base trim in 3 out of 3 model comparisons. Tesla offers a greater towing capacity in 1 out of 2 comparisons. In 1 comparisons, Honda and Tesla have the same towing capacity.
Honda versus Tesla: Quality, Reliability, Safety, and Value Retention Ratings: A comparison of Honda versus Tesla overall quality ratings shows Honda with higher quality ratings in 2 out of 2 model comparisons. In terms of reliability ratings, Honda has the advantage in 2 out of 2 comparisons. Tesla has better safety ratings in 3 out of 3 comparisons. Honda shows higher ratings for retained value in 3 out of 3 comparisons.
Best Car Rankings:
Most Reliable Car Rankings:
Safest Car Rankings:
Available Body Styles: Honda offers 6 SUVs, 3 sedans, 1 hatchback, and 1 minivan. In comparison, Tesla offers 2 SUVs and 2 sedans.
Drivetrain Options: Honda offers 8 gasoline vehicles, 2 hybrids, and 1 electric vehicle. Tesla offers 5 electric vehicles.
Honda offers 7 all-wheel-drive models and 9 front-wheel-drive models. Tesla offers 5 all-wheel-drive models and 2 rear-wheel-drive models.
New Car Pricing
Honda CR-V
$31,804 - $37,965
Honda Civic
$25,044 - $32,100
Honda Pilot
$43,623 - $56,129
New Car Pricing
Tesla Model Y
Not Yet Available
Tesla Model 3
Not Yet Available
Tesla Model X
Not Yet Available
Used Car Pricing
Honda CR-V
$30,000 - $37,944
Honda Civic
$24,951 - $32,094
Honda Pilot
$41,454 - $54,880
Used Car Pricing
Tesla Model Y
$39,977 - $51,617
Tesla Model 3
$25,605 - $41,197
Tesla Model X
Not Yet Available
5-Year Depreciation (Lower is better)
Honda CR-V
31.1%
Honda Civic
23.5%
Honda Pilot
43.6%
5-Year Depreciation (Lower is better)
Tesla Model Y
53.4%
Tesla Model 3
46.7%
Tesla Model X
55.2%
Horsepower / Torque
Honda CR-V
190 hp / 179 foot-lbs
Honda Civic
158 hp / 138 foot-lbs
Honda Pilot
285 hp / 262 foot-lbs
Horsepower / Torque
Tesla Model Y
295 hp / 309 foot-lbs
Tesla Model 3
271 hp / 310 foot-lbs
Tesla Model X
670 hp
MPG (city/highway/combined)
Honda CR-V
28 / 34 / 30
Honda Civic
31 / 40 / 35
Honda Pilot
Not Yet Available
MPG (city/highway/combined)
Tesla Model Y
Not Yet Available
Tesla Model 3
127 / 126 / 127
Tesla Model X
Not Yet Available
iSeeCars Overall Quality Ratings
Honda CR-V
8.9 / 10
Honda Civic
9.0 / 10
Honda Pilot
8.7 / 10
iSeeCars Overall Quality Ratings
Tesla Model Y
Not available
Tesla Model 3
8.3 / 10
Tesla Model X
8.4 / 10
iSeeCars Reliability Ratings
Honda CR-V
9.0 / 10
Honda Civic
8.8 / 10
Honda Pilot
9.2 / 10
iSeeCars Reliability Ratings
Tesla Model Y
Not available
Tesla Model 3
7.2 / 10
Tesla Model X
8.1 / 10
iSeeCars Safety Ratings
Honda CR-V
9.0 / 10
Honda Civic
9.0 / 10
Honda Pilot
9.0 / 10
iSeeCars Safety Ratings
Tesla Model Y
10 / 10
Tesla Model 3
10 / 10
Tesla Model X
10 / 10
iSeeCars Resale Value Ratings
Honda CR-V
8.6 / 10
Honda Civic
9.0 / 10
Honda Pilot
7.8 / 10
iSeeCars Resale Value Ratings
Tesla Model Y
7.2 / 10
Tesla Model 3
7.6 / 10
Tesla Model X
7.1 / 10
iSeeCars Best Car Rankings
Honda Civic
#3 of 26 in
Best Compact Cars
Honda Pilot
#5 of 18 in
Best 8-seater SUVs
iSeeCars Best Car Rankings
Tesla Model 3
#1 of 26 in
Best Electric Cars
Tesla Model X
#1 of 44 in
Best Electric SUVs
iSeeCars Most Reliable Car Rankings
Honda Civic
#2 of 43 in
Most Reliable Small Cars
Honda Pilot
#1 of 67 in
Most Reliable Crossover SUVs
iSeeCars Most Reliable Car Rankings
Tesla Model 3
#2 of 15 in
Most Reliable Luxury Electric Cars
Tesla Model X
#2 of 44 in
Most Reliable Electric SUVs
iSeeCars Safest Car Rankings
Honda CR-V
#29 of 67 in
Safest Crossover SUVs
Honda Civic
#23 of 43 in
Safest Small Cars
Honda Pilot
#16 of 39 in
Safest SUVs with 3 Rows
iSeeCars Safest Car Rankings
Tesla Model Y
#6 of 44 in
Safest Electric SUVs
Tesla Model 3
#1 of 26 in
Safest Electric Cars
Tesla Model X
#1 of 44 in
Safest Electric SUVs