Overview

2019_4runner_trd_off_road_05_16de7b5c9a87ca451ba7165ce44aed44e554b502-1500x1000

Overview (Final Score: C)

The 4Runner is a traditional body-on-frame (truck-based) sport utility, but competes in an arena full of more modern crossover (car-based) utilities. The 2019 4Runner continues with the now long in the tooth design of this-generation 4Runner, introduced in 2010. Compared to most crossovers, the 2019 4Runner is far more off-road-ready and muscular in capability as a traditional SUV.

For the 2019 model year, the Toyota 4Runner sees a few changes to specific trim packages. The TRD Pro off-road package now has new Fox shock absorbers, a new roof rack and skid plate, and includes a sunroof and JBL sound system as standard. A new Limited Nightshade Edition 4Runner trim package adds a black-out color scheme to the 4Runner's top-end package options.

The 4Runner is a very capable off-road goer and "get there" SUV, but it lacks refinement on the road and isn't well suited for family hauling on the daily.

The 2019 Toyota 4Runner is a midsized SUV available in seven trim levels. There is only one engine and transmission option, but drivetrain options include both rear-wheel and four-wheel drive.

What We Love About the 2019 Toyota 4Runner:


  • Many 4WD packages offer nearly unmatched off-road capability

  • Configurations are greatly varied, allowing for versatility in purchase options

  • Cargo space is well-suited to multiple uses and towing is unusually good


What We Don't Love About the 2019 Toyota 4Runner:


  • Poor fuel economy, even for an off-road machine

  • Ride quality on the road is uncomfortable and loud

  • Ergonomics for daily use are some of the worst in the segment


2019_4runner_trd_off_road_06_17c32570d68858afc7411a83baf6e8cd7f92de4f-1500x1000

Exterior View (9/10)

The 2019 Toyota 4Runner has an exterior design that is very closely related to the Tacoma pickup truck it shares much with. The 4Runner has many things in common with the Tacoma, including powertrain components and capabilities. Interior elements are also often shared between the SUV and its pickup truck sibling.

The 4Runner has a less polarizing look than does the Tacoma, however, thanks to its bulkier body styling and bigger presence. As an SUV, the 4Runner has a more robust feel to its appearance. He muscular look of the 4Runner gives it a lot of appeal for buyers, explaining much of its draw and high sales figures. The wide intake, large headlamps, and protruding hood are strong statements in today's market.

The Toyota 4Runner's off-road capability is announced by its large, trapezoidal wheel wells, simple bodywork, and large amounts of wheel and ground clearance. The tall stance and utilitarian design of the 4Runner make no bones about its capabilities off the pavement. Some angled edges and fender design cuts mimic the upper roofline and heavy rack of the 4Runner as well.

Interior Comfort, Quality, Ergonomics (7/10)

The functional interior of the 2019 Toyota 4Runner is robust but comprised of a lot of hard plastics and unadorned surfaces. The strength of the design is in its utilitarian appeal, but many will not find that to their liking. Nevertheless, materials quality in the 4Runner is good and the layout is functionally excellent.

Front seating in the 2019 4Runner is well-done with a comfortable, roomy design that offers a lot of adjustment. The driver may not like the truck-like seating position in the 4Runner, but this goes along with the SUV's overall motif. We like the cloth upholstery and tough leatherette options the 4Runner has, which are all made to do well with rough use.

The second row in the 2019 4Runner is plain but useful and accessible. The bench can haul three kids across or two adults comfortably. Three child safety seats, however, will be a chore to install and three adults will have to squeeze at the shoulders to fit across the 4Runners rear bench. There are some seat adjustment options, including tilting, in the upper trim levels of the 4Runner.

The third row in the Toyota 4Runner is only for kids. Adults will find it hard to access, cramped, and very uncomfortable. These extra two seating positions, which are optional in the 2019 4Runner, are capable of holding two children with or without child safety seats or boosters. The third row eliminates some cargo storage and convenience options, like the sliding tray.

Cargo space in the 2019 Toyota 4Runner is good for the class, with 9 cubic feet behind the third row, 47.2 cubic feet with the third row deleted or folded down, and 89.7 cubic feet with the second row down. The second row will fold totally flat if it's manipulated correctly, but the tall headrests mean maneuvering the front seats forward to make this happen.

The 4Runner features a flat, wide cargo floor, but at a high height that makes loading difficult with bulkier items.

Technology (6/10)

The 2019 Toyota 4Runner offers previous-generation Toyota infotainment and tech options, falling well behind most in this segment. The clunky, outdated, and not very appealing infotainment in the 4Runner is only made worse by a lack of safety and driver's aid options in the SUV.

The base model 4Runner includes a 6.1-inch touchscreen with upgrades going to an 8-inch screen. The screen is good-sized for the SUV but has yesteryear graphics quality and not much connectivity beyond Bluetooth. Previous-generation Entune offers Pandora and Yelp with a Premium setup and requires a way to stream data for usage.

2019_4runner_trd_off_road_08_8b6486dd31b6fe393277c62942ea79e294751bff-1500x1000

Fuel Economy (6/10)

There is only one engine and transmission option for the 2019 4Runner. It's EPA-rated at 17 mpg in the city and 21 mpg on the highway in rear-wheel drive. Going to four-wheel drive drops those numbers to 17 mpg in the city and 20 mpg on the highway. These are low numbers for the midsize segment. They're also optimistic compared to real-world returns.

Our week with the 2019 Toyota 4Runner saw only 16 mpg as an overall number. These match last year's returns in a more off-road-oriented version of the 4Runner and match similar returns from the year before as well. Showing the 4Runner is at least consistent in MPG numbers.

Predicted Reliability, Initial Quality Ratings (9/10)

The 2019 4Runner has received a "Better Than Most" rating from J.D. Power and Associates in their Vehicle Dependability Study. This is the second year in a row for that rating, which boosts our view of the 4Runner this model year. There is only one recall for the 4Runner and it was only for mislabeled parts. The 4Runner has a standard warranty that is about average for the segment.

Safety (7/10)

The 2019 Toyota 4Runner has received a four-star (out of five) overall rating from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). This includes a 4-Star rating for frontal crashes, a 5-Star rating for side crashes, and a 3-Star rating for rollovers.

The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) has given the 2019 4Runner top scores of "Good" for most crash tests. The exception being a second-worst possible "Marginal" rating for small overlap front driver-side test results.

Performance (8/10)

The 2019 Toyota 4Runner has a 4.0-liter six-cylinder engine and a five-speed automatic transmission. The engine outputs 270 horsepower and 278 pound-feet of torque. Rear-wheel drive is standard in most trim options with four-wheel drive as an option. Some off-road-centric trims, such as the TRD packages, include 4WD as standard.

The 4Runner is a solid goer, but not exciting or really quick in most situations. On the road, the SUV is loud and has a mushy drive quality that doesn't inspire a lot of confidence around corners or on a merge. The transmission shifts often, but hesitantly, and the engine takes a while to get up to peak power output.

The off-road packages for the 4Runner are really where it's at for this rig. These offer the equipment to take full advantage of the 4Runner's design, allowing the SUV to become very capable off the pavement. For those looking for an adventure-ready rig, the 4Runner offers a lot of options and goodness. For those looking for a family hauler and daily drive, this probably isn't the best choice.

Pricing and Value (8/10)

Taking the 2019 Toyota 4Runner as it is, it's a great value for those looking for something specific and a terrible one for those looking for anything else. For towing, off-road going, and utility uses, the 4Runner is largely unmatched as a package. For everything else, it's a bad fit.

For options, we'd suggest the SR5 base model or SR5 Premium and the 4WD upgrade as good value options for the 2019 4Runner. For those who need serious off-pavement capability, the TRD Off-Road models are more spendy, but well worth the price for their extensive capability in that arena. We'd forego the expensive Limited and TRD Pro models of the 4Runner.

Resale for the Toyota 4Runner is good and adds to its value proposition on the whole.

2019_4runner_trd_off_road_07_61f00d5c255369acdc59aeadfbb2e42e4381bac7-1500x1500

Total Score and Competitive Comparison (60/80, 75%)

The competition against the 2019 Toyota 4Runner is pretty slim, given its truck-based SUV build. The Chevrolet Traverse is a better family rig, the Jeep Cherokee and Grand Cherokee are largely just as capable off-road against non-TRD models of the 4Runner, and the GMC Acadia offers more premium styling and appeal. All of these options are more comfortable and daily-use friendly. None are as low-cost or package-ready for off-pavement as the 4Runner can be.

The 2019 4Runner is aimed towards sport utility buyers of the old school, who need off-road capability more than any other metric. Compared to family-oriented crossovers and more comfortable road-going SUV options, the 4Runner stands alone as a serious SUV.

Trim Style Engine Drive Train MSRP
SUV - 4WD
SR5 SR5 4WD (Natl) V6 4WD 37185
TRD Off Road TRD Off Road 4WD (Natl) V6 4WD 38485
SR5 Premium SR5 Premium 4WD (Natl) V6 4WD 39015
TRD Off Road Premium TRD Off Road Premium 4WD (Natl) V6 4WD 40395
Limited Limited 4WD (Natl) V6 4WD 45660
TRD Pro TRD Pro 4WD (Natl) V6 4WD 46815
Limited Nightshade Limited Nightshade 4WD (Natl) V6 4WD 47400
SUV - RWD
SR5 SR5 2WD (Natl) V6 RWD 35310
SR5 Premium SR5 Premium 2WD (Natl) V6 RWD 37140
Limited Limited 2WD (Natl) V6 RWD 43625
Limited Nightshade Limited Nightshade 2WD (Natl) V6 RWD 45365

Comparison of 2019 Toyota 4Runner with Similar Cars

2019 Toyota 4Runner MSRP Invoice
2019 Toyota 4runner $35,310 $32,486
Similar Cars to Consider MSRP Invoice Compare
2019 Acura RDX $37,400 $35,511 2019 Toyota 4runner VS 2019 Acura RDX
2019 BMW X1 $34,950 $33,005 2019 Toyota 4runner VS 2019 BMW X1
2019 Lincoln MKC $33,995 $32,465 2019 Toyota 4runner VS 2019 Lincoln MKC
2019 Mercedes-Benz Gla-Class $33,950 $31,913 2019 Toyota 4runner VS 2019 Mercedes-Benz Gla-Class
2019 Infiniti Qx50 $36,650 $34,451 2019 Toyota 4runner VS 2019 Infiniti Qx50

Car Rankings

Interested to see how the 2019 Toyota 4Runner ranks against similar cars in terms of key attributes? Here are the 2019 Toyota 4Runner rankings for MPG, horsepower, torque, leg room, head room, shoulder room, hip room and so forth.

Toyota 4Runner SUVs for Sale

Similar SUVs for Sale

Powered by Chrome