Maguire Subaru of Ithaca in Ithaca, NY
Dealer Analysis 20 Deals Found
33 Cars for sale now, starting at $12,499
Avg. Price: 26747.6
Typical Price Range: 14399.0–38319.0
Average Savings ($) Below Market Price
Avg. Savings: $1,893
Save up to $3,879 below est. market price
% of Used Cars That Are Deals
Avg. Mileage: 42471.9
Typical Mileage Range: 8206.0–87868.4
% of Listings with Valid Price, Mileage, and Photo
- This Dealer
- Average Dealer
Maguire Subaru of Ithaca is given a 4.8 "overall dealer rating" based on our analysis of 349 cars the dealer recently listed for sale. This assesses the dealer's price competitiveness, responsiveness to inquiries, and information transparency (how good the dealers are at providing basic information such as vehicle photos, price and mileage).
Inventory Analysis
Vehicle Age
Top Makes
Top Bodystyles
Domestic/Foreign
Luxury/Non-Luxury
Showing 1-20 of 33 Listings
Sort by:
$12,499
$12,999
GREAT DEAL
2014 Mazda MAZDA6 i Touring
- 52,245 Miles
- Listed 58 days ago
- Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
- $2,678 Below market value of $15,177
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2014 Mazda MAZDA6 i Touring for Sale
52,245 Miles
Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $12,499 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JM1GJ1V6XE1124020 |
| Location | Ithaca, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 52,245 mi. |
| Transmission | Automatic |
| Exterior Color | White |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 30 combined |
| Drivetrain | Front-wheel drive |
$13,999
$14,999
GREAT DEAL
2019 Hyundai Sonata Limited
- 80,058 Miles
- Listed 39 days ago
- Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
- $1,946 Below market value of $15,945
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2019 Hyundai Sonata Limited for Sale
80,058 Miles
Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $13,999 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 5NPE34AF3KH778676 |
| Location | Ithaca, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, leather upholstery, internet radio |
| Mileage | 80,058 mi. |
| Transmission | Automatic |
| Exterior Color | Gray |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 28 combined |
| Drivetrain | Front-wheel drive |
$25,499
$26,499
GREAT DEAL
2022 Hyundai Tucson Limited
- 21,910 Miles
- Listed 66 days ago
- Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
- $3,184 Below market value of $28,683
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2022 Hyundai Tucson Limited for Sale
21,910 Miles
Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $25,499 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 5NMJECAE4NH144773 |
| Location | Ithaca, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, navigation, backup camera, leather upholstery |
| Mileage | 21,910 mi. |
| Transmission | Automatic |
| Exterior Color | Gray |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 26 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$25,499
$25,999
GREAT DEAL
2024 Subaru Crosstrek Limited
- 27,051 Miles
- Listed 73 days ago
- Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
- $3,879 Below market value of $29,378
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2024 Subaru Crosstrek Limited for Sale
27,051 Miles
Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $25,499 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 4S4GUHM65R3706520 |
| Location | Ithaca, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, leather upholstery, internet radio |
| Mileage | 27,051 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Gray |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$25,999
$26,999
GOOD DEAL
2023 Subaru Crosstrek Limited
- 16,724 Miles
- Listed 56 days ago
- Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
- $2,469 Below market value of $28,468
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2023 Subaru Crosstrek Limited for Sale
16,724 Miles
Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $25,999 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2GTHMC2P8296628 |
| Location | Ithaca, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, leather upholstery, internet radio |
| Mileage | 16,724 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Gray |
| Interior Color | Gray |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$14,999
$15,999
GOOD DEAL
2016 Mazda CX-5 Grand Touring
- 84,227 Miles
- Listed 38 days ago
- Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
- $1,272 Below market value of $16,271
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2016 Mazda CX-5 Grand Touring for Sale
84,227 Miles
Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $14,999 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JM3KE4DY9G0844847 |
| Location | Ithaca, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, leather upholstery, internet radio |
| Mileage | 84,227 mi. |
| Transmission | Automatic |
| Exterior Color | Silver |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 26 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$28,499
$29,499
GOOD DEAL
2023 Subaru Forester Limited
- 21,001 Miles
- Listed 51 days ago
- Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
- $2,349 Below market value of $30,848
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2023 Subaru Forester Limited for Sale
21,001 Miles
Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $28,499 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2SKAPC4PH422150 |
| Location | Ithaca, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, leather upholstery, internet radio |
| Mileage | 21,001 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | White |
| Interior Color | Gray |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$28,999
$30,999
GOOD DEAL
2025 Subaru Crosstrek Limited
- 9,141 Miles
- Listed 64 days ago
- Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
- $2,763 Below market value of $31,762
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2025 Subaru Crosstrek Limited for Sale
9,141 Miles
Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $28,999 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 4S4GUHM60S3704552 |
| Location | Ithaca, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, leather upholstery, internet radio |
| Mileage | 9,141 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Gray |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$16,999
$18,499
GOOD DEAL
2020 Hyundai Santa Fe SEL
- 69,418 Miles
- Listed 35 days ago
- Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
- $1,527 Below market value of $18,526
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2020 Hyundai Santa Fe SEL for Sale
69,418 Miles
Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $16,999 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 5NMS33ADXLH194348 |
| Location | Ithaca, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, alloy wheels, satellite radio |
| Mileage | 69,418 mi. |
| Transmission | Automatic |
| Exterior Color | Green |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 25 combined |
| Drivetrain | Front-wheel drive |
$34,999
$35,999
GOOD DEAL
2025 Subaru Forester Touring
- 7,672 Miles
- Listed 77 days ago
- Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
- $3,138 Below market value of $38,137
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2025 Subaru Forester Touring for Sale
7,672 Miles
Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $34,999 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2SLDTCXSH496461 |
| Location | Ithaca, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, navigation, backup camera, internet radio |
| Mileage | 7,672 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Black |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 28 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$20,499
$21,999
GOOD DEAL
2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium
- 35,900 Miles
- Listed 17 days ago
- Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
- $559 Below market value of $21,058
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium for Sale
35,900 Miles
Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $20,499 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2SJAGC3JH459247 |
| Location | Ithaca, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, sunroof |
| Mileage | 35,900 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Blue |
| Interior Color | Gray |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$19,999
$20,499
GOOD DEAL
2018 Subaru Outback 2.5i Limited
- 57,187 Miles
- Listed 39 days ago
- Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
- $1,022 Below market value of $21,021
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2018 Subaru Outback 2.5i Limited for Sale
57,187 Miles
Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $19,999 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 4S4BSANCXJ3207499 |
| Location | Ithaca, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, leather upholstery, internet radio |
| Mileage | 57,187 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Blue |
| Interior Color | White |
| MPG | 28 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$37,499
GOOD DEAL
2023 Hyundai Palisade Limited
- 28,691 Miles
- Listed 11 days ago
- Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
- $1,184 Below market value of $38,683
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2023 Hyundai Palisade Limited for Sale
28,691 Miles
Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $37,499 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 6-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 7 Seats |
| VIN | KM8R5DGE2PU615889 |
| Location | Ithaca, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, captain's chair, child safety, navigation, backup camera |
| Mileage | 28,691 mi. |
| Transmission | Automatic |
| Exterior Color | White |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 21 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$29,999
$30,999
GOOD DEAL
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
- 9,204 Miles
- Listed 77 days ago
- Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
- $2,190 Below market value of $32,189
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2025 Subaru Forester Premium for Sale
9,204 Miles
Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $29,999 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2SLDDC6SH486136 |
| Location | Ithaca, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, sunroof |
| Mileage | 9,204 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Green |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$31,499
$31,999
GOOD DEAL
2023 Hyundai Santa Fe Calligraphy
- 20,129 Miles
- Listed 60 days ago
- Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
- $1,620 Below market value of $33,119
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2023 Hyundai Santa Fe Calligraphy for Sale
20,129 Miles
Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $31,499 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 5NMS5DAL1PH593307 |
| Location | Ithaca, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, navigation, backup camera, leather upholstery |
| Mileage | 20,129 mi. |
| Transmission | Automatic |
| Exterior Color | Blue |
| Interior Color | Brown |
| MPG | 24 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$24,499
$24,999
GOOD DEAL
2021 Subaru Crosstrek Limited
- 26,026 Miles
- Listed 89 days ago
- Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
- $1,496 Below market value of $25,995
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2021 Subaru Crosstrek Limited for Sale
26,026 Miles
Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $24,499 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2GTHMC0M8213824 |
| Location | Ithaca, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, leather upholstery, internet radio |
| Mileage | 26,026 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | White |
| Interior Color | Gray |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$21,999
GOOD DEAL
2020 Subaru Ascent Limited 7-Passenger
- 85,213 Miles
- Listed 16 days ago
- Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
- $987 Below market value of $22,986
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2020 Subaru Ascent Limited 7-Passenger for Sale
85,213 Miles
Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $21,999 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 7 Seats |
| VIN | 4S4WMAPD0L3431840 |
| Location | Ithaca, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, captain's chair, child safety, backup camera, leather upholstery |
| Mileage | 85,213 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | White |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 22 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$23,499
$23,999
GOOD DEAL
2024 Hyundai Kona SEL
- 17,526 Miles
- Listed 39 days ago
- Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
- $605 Below market value of $24,104
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2024 Hyundai Kona SEL for Sale
17,526 Miles
Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $23,499 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | KM8HBCAB6RU054936 |
| Location | Ithaca, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, navigation, backup camera, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 17,526 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Gray |
| Interior Color | Gray |
| MPG | 28 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$32,499
$35,499
GOOD DEAL
2025 Subaru Outback Limited
- 12,865 Miles
- Listed 89 days ago
- Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
- $2,223 Below market value of $34,722
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2025 Subaru Outback Limited for Sale
12,865 Miles
Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $32,499 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 4S4BTANC1S3118113 |
| Location | Ithaca, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, navigation, backup camera, leather upholstery |
| Mileage | 12,865 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | White |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 28 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$23,999
$24,999
GOOD DEAL
2023 Hyundai Kona N Base
- 42,501 Miles
- Listed 31 days ago
- Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
- $771 Below market value of $24,770
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2023 Hyundai Kona N Base for Sale
42,501 Miles
Ithaca, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $23,999 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | KM8KH3AC1PU010241 |
| Location | Ithaca, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, navigation, backup camera, leather upholstery |
| Mileage | 42,501 mi. |
| Transmission | Automatic |
| Exterior Color | White |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 23 combined |
| Drivetrain | Front-wheel drive |
Page 1 of 2
Other Nearby Dealers
Used Cars for Sale Insights
Find More Cars For Sale
Explore Models
Ford F-150
Save $26,402 on 16,219 Deals
102,684 Listings from $1,250
102,684 Listings from $1,250
Toyota Camry
Save $7,150 on 6,221 Deals
31,552 Listings from $975
31,552 Listings from $975
Honda Civic
Save $8,551 on 5,668 Deals
29,113 Listings from $1,000
29,113 Listings from $1,000
Chevrolet Equinox
Save $6,520 on 7,953 Deals
37,786 Listings from $1,099
37,786 Listings from $1,099
Ford Edge
Save $6,903 on 4,678 Deals
13,187 Listings from $1,500
13,187 Listings from $1,500
GMC Sierra 1500
Save $13,742 on 7,775 Deals
41,812 Listings from $1,000
41,812 Listings from $1,000
Nissan Sentra
Save $6,497 on 2,944 Deals
27,802 Listings from $1,200
27,802 Listings from $1,200
Toyota Highlander
Save $10,027 on 4,704 Deals
11,858 Listings from $1,800
11,858 Listings from $1,800
Nissan Versa
Save $4,191 on 955 Deals
11,250 Listings from $1,900
11,250 Listings from $1,900
Jeep Compass
Save $6,226 on 4,292 Deals
17,960 Listings from $1,975
17,960 Listings from $1,975