Used Toyota Highlander for Sale by Owner & Dealer in Indianapolis, IN

1-20 of 198 Cars Found
Save Search
X

Message:

2012 Toyota Highlander Limited

2012 Toyota Highlander Limited - 115,101 mi

Indianapolis, IN (6 mi) - Listed 45 days ago
  • $3,410 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • free CARFAX
$12,995
PREVIEW
2006 Toyota Highlander Base

2006 Toyota Highlander Base - 141,994 mi

Westfield, IN (18 mi) - Listed 8 days ago
  • $990 below market price
  • dealer rating
PREVIEW
iSeeCars Unbiased Insights

How can you save money on a used Toyota Highlander?

  • Highlander

    $30,285
    $8,549 Savings

    Highlander Hybrid

    $38,834
  • 4-Cylinder

    $25,254
    $4,727 Savings

    6-Cylinder

    $29,982
  • FWD

    $27,753
    $2,961 Savings

    AWD

    $30,714

iSeeCars analyzes over 25 billion data points to help you find the best deals.
See more ways to save.

iSeeCars Unbiased Insights

Does car color affect the price of a used Toyota Highlander?

Least
Expensive

Red

$1,162Average Savings

Most
Expensive

Beige

$453Average Premium

iSeeCars analyzes over 25 billion data points to help you find the best deals.
See more ways to save.

2012 Toyota Highlander Limited

2012 Toyota Highlander Limited - 107,218 mi

Greenfield, IN (19 mi) - Listed 27 days ago
  • $733 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 2 positives , free CARFAX
$16,833
PREVIEW
Home Delivery
2020 Toyota Highlander Platinum

2020 Toyota Highlander Platinum - 1,598 mi

Lebanon, IN (26 mi) - Listed 58 days ago
  • $1,281 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • low miles , free CARFAX
$47,000
PREVIEW
2012 Toyota Highlander Limited

2012 Toyota Highlander Limited - 47,390 mi

Shelbyville, IN (24 mi) - Listed 13 days ago
  • $122 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner , 2 positives , low miles , free CARFAX
PREVIEW
2019 Toyota Highlander SE

2019 Toyota Highlander SE - 16,828 mi

Indianapolis, IN (10 mi) - Listed 15 days ago
  • $344 above market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner , low miles , free CARFAX
PREVIEW
Home Delivery
2010 Toyota Highlander Base

2010 Toyota Highlander Base - 118,993 mi

Indianapolis, IN (9 mi) - Listed 3 days ago
  • $238 above market price
  • dealer rating
  • free CARFAX
PREVIEW
2011 Toyota Highlander Limited

2011 Toyota Highlander Limited - 109,975 mi

Bloomington, IN (49 mi) - Listed 37 days ago
  • $193 above market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner , free CARFAX
PREVIEW
Home Delivery
2020 Toyota Highlander Limited

2020 Toyota Highlander Limited - 7,574 mi

Indianapolis, IN (9 mi) - Listed 16 days ago
  • $40 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • low miles
PREVIEW
Home Delivery
2018 Toyota Highlander Limited

2018 Toyota Highlander Limited - 35,473 mi

- Listed 1 day ago
  • $1,341 above market price
  • low miles
PREVIEW
View on partner site
2015 Toyota Highlander Limited

2015 Toyota Highlander Limited - 120,812 mi

Kokomo, IN (45 mi) - Listed 1 day ago
  • $691 above market price
  • dealer rating
  • free CARFAX
PREVIEW
Home Delivery
2020 Toyota Highlander LE

2020 Toyota Highlander LE - 19,345 mi

Indianapolis, IN (7 mi) - Listed 67 days ago
  • $819 above market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner , free CARFAX
PREVIEW
Home Delivery
2017 Toyota Highlander SE

2017 Toyota Highlander SE - 73,524 mi

Indianapolis, IN (9 mi) - Listed 37 days ago
  • $1,230 above market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner , free CARFAX
$28,995
PREVIEW
Home Delivery
2019 Toyota Highlander XLE

2019 Toyota Highlander XLE - 16,140 mi

Bloomington, IN (49 mi) - Listed 37 days ago
  • $632 above market price
  • dealer rating
  • low miles
$36,500
PREVIEW
Home Delivery
2018 Toyota Highlander Limited Platinum

2018 Toyota Highlander Limited Plat - 73,181 mi

Noblesville, IN (21 mi) - Listed 44 days ago
  • $791 above market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner , free CARFAX , high miles
PREVIEW
Home Delivery
2021 Toyota Highlander XLE

2021 Toyota Highlander XLE - 4,506 mi

Greenwood, IN (14 mi) - Listed 47 days ago
  • $1,684 above market price
  • low miles
  • 2 price drops in 48 days
$42,980
PREVIEW
2019 Toyota Highlander XLE

2019 Toyota Highlander XLE - 30,900 mi

Noblesville, IN (21 mi) - Listed 23 days ago
  • $1,346 above market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner , certified used , low miles , free CARFAX
$34,439
PREVIEW
2017 Toyota Highlander LE Plus

2017 Toyota Highlander LE Plus - 57,982 mi

Noblesville, IN (21 mi) - Listed 9 days ago
  • $2,828 above market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner , certified used , 2 positives , low miles , free CARFAX
PREVIEW
2018 Toyota Highlander XLE

2018 Toyota Highlander XLE - 76,041 mi

Avon, IN (16 mi) - Listed 16 days ago
  • dealer rating
  • certified used , 4 positives , free CARFAX , high miles
PREVIEW
Home Delivery
2015 Toyota Highlander Limited

2015 Toyota Highlander Limited - 52,672 mi

Indianapolis, IN (9 mi) - Listed 7 days ago
  • market price $26,819
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner , low miles , free CARFAX
PREVIEW
X
Would you like to view the latest search results ?
Yes     No
Zip Code Required X

Please enter a five-digit zip code to find cars for sale near you.

What is the average price for Used Toyota Highlander for Sale in Indianapolis, IN? How many are for sale and priced below market?

  • 198 cars for sale found, starting at $3,495
  • Average price for Used Toyota Highlander Indianapolis, IN: $33,421
  • 8 deals found. Average savings of $1,362
  • Save up to $3,410 below estimated market price

Used Toyota Highlander Pricing in Indianapolis

Average Price
$33,421
For a used Toyota Highlander
Average Savings
$1,362
Based on all Highlander deals found
Biggest Savings
$3,410
Below estimated market price
Good Deal
$25,488
Typical price of a good deal
Search for a used Toyota Highlander in Indianapolis
See my listings

How to save money when buying a used Toyota Highlander in Indianapolis?

Fuel Type A Highlander averages $8,549 less than a Highlander Hybrid
Engine A 4-Cylinder Highlander costs $4,727 less than a 6-Cylinder
Drive Type A front-wheel drive (FWD) Toyota Highlander can be priced $2,961 less than an all-wheel drive (AWD)

What colors are the best deals for a Toyota Highlander in Indianapolis?

Least Expensive Color
Red $1,162Average Savings
Most Expensive Color
Beige $453Average Premium

What Toyota Highlander color has the best resale value in Indianapolis?

Price differences by car color compared to the average price of a used Toyota Highlander in Indianapolis

Average car color pricing for a used Toyota Highlander in Indianapolis?

Rank Color Compared to Avg Price
1 Red $1,162 Savings
2 Green $719 Savings
3 Gray $675 Savings
4 Black $295 Savings
5 Blue $75 Savings
6 Silver $4 Higher
7 White $189 Higher
8 Brown $418 Higher
9 Beige $453 Higher

What is the best time to buy a used Toyota Highlander in Indianapolis?

Good times to buy
- Save $274 on average: January, September, October, November, December are good times to buy to find the best prices.
Good times to sell
- Make an extra $198 on average: February, March, April, May, June, July, August are good times to sell to get the best prices
Total saved by iSeeCars users

$284,807,013

Start searching smarter now

Top Dealers Listing Used Toyota Highlander for Sale in Indianapolis, IN

Ed Martin Toyota
Noblesville, IN
3.4 stars
22 Used Toyota Highlander for Sale in Indianapolis, IN for sale
Tom Wood Toyota
Whitestown, IN
3.6 stars
19 Used Toyota Highlander for Sale in Indianapolis, IN for sale
Andy Mohr Toyota
Avon, IN
3.9 stars
18 Used Toyota Highlander for Sale in Indianapolis, IN for sale

Price of Used Toyota Highlander for Sale in Indianapolis, IN by Distance

Distance from Indianapolis, IN Average Price Deals Listings
50 miles
$33,695 Save $3,410 on 8 deals 151 listings
100 miles
$31,154 Save $3,410 on 19 deals 400 listings
200 miles
$32,335 Save $3,410 on 47 deals 1,535 listings

Similar Models

Average Price Deals Listings
BMW X1 for Sale $30,060 Save $8,496 on 281 deals 4,062 listings
Chevrolet Traverse for Sale $27,793 Save $9,835 on 543 deals 12,239 listings
Dodge Durango for Sale $33,186 Save $11,855 on 308 deals 9,558 listings
Ford Explorer for Sale $32,429 Save $9,155 on 1,155 deals 32,632 listings
Honda Pilot for Sale $33,008 Save $9,166 on 524 deals 17,298 listings
Hyundai Santa Fe for Sale $29,243 Save $4,579 on 342 deals 14,681 listings
Jeep Grand Cherokee for Sale $32,318 Save $9,306 on 1,170 deals 32,166 listings
Mazda CX-9 for Sale $30,096 Save $8,102 on 139 deals 3,589 listings
Nissan Murano for Sale $28,399 Save $7,119 on 459 deals 11,562 listings
Nissan Pathfinder for Sale $22,829 Save $5,599 on 372 deals 7,324 listings

Used Toyota Highlander By Model Year

Year Average Price Deals Listings
2021 Toyota Highlander in Indianapolis
$45,672 - 53 listings
2020 Toyota Highlander in Indianapolis
$40,223 Save $1,281 on 1 deal 5 listings
2019 Toyota Highlander in Indianapolis
$35,752 - 19 listings
2018 Toyota Highlander in Indianapolis
$33,436 - 24 listings
2017 Toyota Highlander in Indianapolis
$29,393 - 7 listings
2016 Toyota Highlander in Indianapolis
$24,884 - 3 listings
2015 Toyota Highlander in Indianapolis
$26,865 - 9 listings
Explore Other Cities
  • Toyota Highlander in Erie 21 Listings from $13,500
  • Toyota Highlander in Idaho Falls 6 Listings from $9,950

Keep me posted on new listings X
By clicking "Subscribe" you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.
Save This Car X
GET ALERTS
By clicking "Start Tracking" you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.
Save This Search X
Be the first to see new listings
and price drops for your search.
GET ALERTS
By clicking "Get Alerts" you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.