Johnstons Subaru in Middletown, NY
Dealer Analysis 2 Deals Found
221 Cars for sale now, starting at $15,490
Avg. Price: 25336.2
Typical Price Range: 14438.4–34493.0
Average Savings ($) Below Market Price
Avg. Savings: $1,197
Save up to $1,525 below est. market price
% of Used Cars That Are Deals
Avg. Mileage: 45686.1
Typical Mileage Range: 5636.2–95408.7
% of Listings with Valid Price, Mileage, and Photo
- This Dealer
- Average Dealer
Johnstons Subaru is not given a rating because there isn't enough information. In general, the overall dealer rating is a measure of the dealer's price competitiveness compared to other dealers and its information transparency which measures how good a dealer is in providing basic information about each vehicle such as photos, price and mileage.
Inventory Analysis
Vehicle Age
Top Makes
Top Bodystyles
Domestic/Foreign
Luxury/Non-Luxury
Showing 1-20 of 221 Listings
Sort by:
$15,490
GOOD DEAL
2015 Subaru Impreza 2.0i Sport Limited
- 31,760 Miles
- Listed 6 days ago
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $1,525 Below market value of $17,015
- Low annual miles
Additional info close
Used 2015 Subaru Impreza 2.0i Sport Limited for Sale
31,760 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $15,490 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF1GPAZ6XF8224870 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, leather upholstery, internet radio |
| Mileage | 31,760 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Quartz blue pearl |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 31 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$17,990
$19,990
GOOD DEAL
2020 Subaru Crosstrek Limited
- 103,251 Miles
- Listed 166 days ago
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $869 Below market value of $18,859
- 1 Owner
Additional info close
Used 2020 Subaru Crosstrek Limited for Sale
103,251 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $17,990 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2GTAMC3L8228551 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, leather upholstery, internet radio |
| Mileage | 103,251 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Magnetite gray metallic |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 30 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$32,490
FAIR DEAL
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
- 4,120 Miles
- Listed 31 days ago
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $135 Above market value of $32,355
- 1 Owner, Certified used, Low annual miles
Additional info close
Used 2025 Subaru Forester Premium for Sale
4,120 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Certified Used Cars |
| Price | $32,490 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2SLDBC4SH454272 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, sunroof |
| Mileage | 4,120 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Magnetite gray metallic |
| Interior Color | Gray |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$22,490
FAIR DEAL
2021 Subaru Outback Premium
- 51,820 Miles
- Listed 17 days ago
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $53 Above market value of $22,543
- 1 Owner, Certified used, Low annual miles
Additional info close
Used 2021 Subaru Outback Premium for Sale
51,820 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Certified Used Cars |
| Price | $22,490 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 4S4BTADC1M3186206 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 51,820 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Ice silver metallic |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$25,490
FAIR DEAL
2023 Subaru Outback Premium
- 39,690 Miles
- Listed 35 days ago
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $439 Above market value of $25,929
- 1 Owner, Certified used
Additional info close
Used 2023 Subaru Outback Premium for Sale
39,690 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Certified Used Cars |
| Price | $25,490 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 4S4BTADC3P3115786 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 39,690 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Crystal white pearl |
| MPG | 28 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$25,990
FAIR DEAL
2023 Subaru Crosstrek Premium
- 13,954 Miles
- Listed 26 days ago
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $651 Above market value of $25,339
- 1 Owner, Certified used, Low annual miles
Additional info close
Used 2023 Subaru Crosstrek Premium for Sale
13,954 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Certified Used Cars |
| Price | $25,990 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2GTAPC3P8216658 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 13,954 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Crystal black silica |
| MPG | 30 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$27,490
FAIR DEAL
2021 Subaru Ascent Touring
- 61,322 Miles
- Listed 70 days ago
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $174 Above market value of $27,664
- 1 Owner, Certified used, Low annual miles
Additional info close
Used 2021 Subaru Ascent Touring for Sale
61,322 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Certified Used Cars |
| Price | $27,490 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 7 Seats |
| VIN | 4S4WMARD4M3403120 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, captain's chair, child safety, navigation, backup camera |
| Mileage | 61,322 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Crystal black silica |
| MPG | 22 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$24,490
FAIR DEAL
2023 Subaru Outback Premium
- 56,175 Miles
- Listed 42 days ago
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $24 Above market value of $24,466
- 1 Owner, Certified used, High annual miles
Additional info close
Used 2023 Subaru Outback Premium for Sale
56,175 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Certified Used Cars |
| Price | $24,490 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 4S4BTACC0P3175669 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 56,175 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Ice silver metallic |
| MPG | 28 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$27,490
$28,990
FAIR DEAL
2024 Subaru Crosstrek Premium
- 21,527 Miles
- Listed 60 days ago
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $810 Above market value of $26,680
- 1 Owner, Certified used, Low annual miles
Additional info close
Used 2024 Subaru Crosstrek Premium for Sale
21,527 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Certified Used Cars |
| Price | $27,490 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2GUADC8RH350764 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 21,527 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Offshore blue metallic |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$26,490
$29,990
FAIR DEAL
2024 Subaru Crosstrek Premium
- 26,098 Miles
- Listed 126 days ago
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $95 Above market value of $26,395
- 1 Owner, Certified used
Additional info close
Used 2024 Subaru Crosstrek Premium for Sale
26,098 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Certified Used Cars |
| Price | $26,490 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2GUADC2RH350226 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 26,098 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Crystal white pearl |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$34,490
$35,990
FAIR DEAL
2024 Subaru Ascent Premium 7-Passenger
- 19,716 Miles
- Listed 129 days ago
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $1,332 Above market value of $33,157
- 1 Owner, Certified used, Low annual miles
Additional info close
Used 2024 Subaru Ascent Premium 7-Passenger for Sale
19,716 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Certified Used Cars |
| Price | $34,490 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 7 Seats |
| VIN | 4S4WMAED2R3444620 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, captain's chair, child safety, backup camera, internet radio |
| Mileage | 19,716 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Ice silver metallic |
| MPG | 22 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$15,990
FAIR DEAL
2017 Subaru Outback 2.5i Limited
- 87,122 Miles
- Listed 10 days ago
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $305 Above market value of $15,685
- 1 Owner, Low annual miles
Additional info close
Used 2017 Subaru Outback 2.5i Limited for Sale
87,122 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $15,990 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 4S4BSANC9H3431860 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, leather upholstery, internet radio |
| Mileage | 87,122 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Carbide gray metallic |
| MPG | 28 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$15,490
FAIR DEAL
2018 Subaru Outback 2.5i
- 83,739 Miles
- Listed 17 days ago
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $91 Above market value of $15,581
- 1 Owner, Low annual miles
Additional info close
Used 2018 Subaru Outback 2.5i for Sale
83,739 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $15,490 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 4S4BSAAC8J3304951 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 83,739 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Magnetite gray metallic |
| Interior Color | Gray |
| MPG | 28 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$25,990
FAIR DEAL
2022 Subaru Outback Premium
- 22,512 Miles
- Listed 4 days ago
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $251 Above market value of $25,739
- Low annual miles
Additional info close
Used 2022 Subaru Outback Premium for Sale
22,512 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $25,990 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 4S4BTACCXN3274187 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 22,512 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Abyss blue pearl |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$24,990
FAIR DEAL
2023 Subaru Crosstrek Premium
- 23,453 Miles
- Listed 20 days ago
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $324 Above market value of $24,666
- 1 Owner, Low annual miles
Additional info close
Used 2023 Subaru Crosstrek Premium for Sale
23,453 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $24,990 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2GTAPC1P8306536 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 23,453 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Desert khaki |
| MPG | 30 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$29,990
FAIR DEAL
2025 Subaru Outback Premium
- 8,426 Miles
- Listed 13 days ago
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $768 Above market value of $29,222
- 1 Owner, Low annual miles
Additional info close
Used 2025 Subaru Outback Premium for Sale
8,426 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $29,990 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 4S4BTACC0S3106103 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 8,426 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Ice silver metallic |
| MPG | 28 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$19,490
FAIR DEAL
2019 Subaru Outback 2.5i Premium
- 53,322 Miles
- Listed 24 days ago
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $552 Above market value of $18,938
- 1 Owner, Low annual miles
Additional info close
Used 2019 Subaru Outback 2.5i Premium for Sale
53,322 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $19,490 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 4S4BSAHC6K3205505 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 53,322 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Abyss blue pearl |
| MPG | 28 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$18,990
FAIR DEAL
2019 Subaru Outback 2.5i Premium
- 59,502 Miles
- Listed 6 days ago
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $690 Above market value of $18,300
- Low annual miles
Additional info close
Used 2019 Subaru Outback 2.5i Premium for Sale
59,502 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $18,990 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 4S4BSAHC2K3262297 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 59,502 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Abyss blue pearl |
| Interior Color | Gray |
| MPG | 28 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$28,990
FAIR DEAL
2021 Subaru Outback Touring XT
- 41,518 Miles
- Listed 30 days ago
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $1,227 Above market value of $27,763
- 1 Owner, Low annual miles
Additional info close
Used 2021 Subaru Outback Touring XT for Sale
41,518 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $28,990 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 4S4BTGPD7M3100162 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, navigation, backup camera, leather upholstery |
| Mileage | 41,518 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Abyss blue pearl |
| Interior Color | Brown |
| MPG | 26 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$27,990
$29,990
FAIR DEAL
2022 Subaru Outback Limited
- 30,703 Miles
- Listed 146 days ago
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $769 Above market value of $27,221
- 1 Owner, Low annual miles
Additional info close
Used 2022 Subaru Outback Limited for Sale
30,703 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $27,990 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 4S4BTANC9N3233997 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, leather upholstery, internet radio |
| Mileage | 30,703 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Ice silver metallic |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
Page 1 of 12
Other Nearby Dealers
Used Cars for Sale Insights
Find More Cars For Sale
Explore Models
Nissan Altima
Save $5,482 on 3,666 Deals
17,249 Listings from $500
17,249 Listings from $500
Toyota Camry
Save $8,267 on 4,284 Deals
25,745 Listings from $1,499
25,745 Listings from $1,499
Toyota Corolla
Save $4,994 on 2,901 Deals
16,861 Listings from $1,000
16,861 Listings from $1,000
Chrysler Town and Country
Save $3,928 on 362 Deals
1,332 Listings from $999
1,332 Listings from $999
Ram Ram Pickup 1500
Save $17,622 on 7,733 Deals
45,996 Listings from $4,000
45,996 Listings from $4,000
Toyota Tacoma
Save $12,722 on 4,139 Deals
32,590 Listings from $4,500
32,590 Listings from $4,500
Ford Super Duty F-250
Save $20,143 on 2,814 Deals
23,613 Listings from $3,999
23,613 Listings from $3,999
Chevrolet Traverse
Save $11,304 on 3,530 Deals
19,721 Listings from $1,999
19,721 Listings from $1,999
Jeep Liberty
Save $3,958 on 159 Deals
606 Listings from $1,499
606 Listings from $1,499
BMW X5
Save $14,416 on 2,696 Deals
10,202 Listings from $1,900
10,202 Listings from $1,900