Johnstons Subaru in Middletown, NY
Dealer Analysis 16 Deals Found
325 Cars for sale now, starting at $12,990
Avg. Price: 25446.8
Typical Price Range: 15990.0–34490.0
Average Savings ($) Below Market Price
Avg. Savings: $2,424
Save up to $5,346 below est. market price
% of Used Cars That Are Deals
Avg. Mileage: 40609.2
Typical Mileage Range: 5613.4–87678.2
% of Listings with Valid Price, Mileage, and Photo
- This Dealer
- Average Dealer
Johnstons Subaru is not given a rating because there isn't enough information. In general, the overall dealer rating is a measure of the dealer's price competitiveness compared to other dealers and its information transparency which measures how good a dealer is in providing basic information about each vehicle such as photos, price and mileage.
Inventory Analysis
Vehicle Age
Top Makes
Top Bodystyles
Domestic/Foreign
Luxury/Non-Luxury
Showing 1-20 of 325 Listings
Sort by:
$22,490
$24,990
GREAT DEAL
2024 Subaru Crosstrek Sport
- 40,039 Miles
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $3,052 Below market value of $25,542
- 1 Owner, Certified used
- Listed 53 days ago
Additional info close
Used 2024 Subaru Crosstrek Sport for Sale
40,039 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Certified Used Cars |
| Price | $22,490 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 4S4GUHF60R3740703 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 40,039 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Crystal white pearl |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$30,003
GREAT DEAL
2022 Mercedes-Benz C-Class C 300 4MATIC
- 18,287 Miles
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $5,346 Below market value of $35,349
- Low annual miles
- Listed 39 days ago
Additional info close
Used 2022 Mercedes-Benz C-Class C 300 4MATIC for Sale
18,287 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $30,003 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | W1KAF4HB2NR008187 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, sunroof, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 18,287 mi. |
| Transmission | Automatic |
| Exterior Color | Gray |
| Interior Color | Brown |
| MPG | 27 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$25,740
$25,840
GREAT DEAL
2022 Ford Explorer XLT
- 30,910 Miles
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $4,440 Below market value of $30,180
- Low annual miles
- Listed 45 days ago
Additional info close
Used 2022 Ford Explorer XLT for Sale
30,910 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $25,740 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 6 Seats |
| VIN | 1FMSK8DH4NGA80639 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, alloy wheels, satellite radio |
| Mileage | 30,910 mi. |
| Transmission | Automatic |
| Exterior Color | Gray |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 22 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$29,400
$29,640
GREAT DEAL
2022 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 LT
- 35,898 Miles
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- Remaining Lifespan: 9.398332 yrs
- $4,798 Below market value of $34,198
- Listed 60 days ago
Additional info close
Used 2022 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 LT for Sale
35,898 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $29,400 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 6 Seats |
| VIN | 1GCPDKEK7NZ619920 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, navigation, backup camera, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 35,898 mi. |
| Transmission | Automatic |
| Exterior Color | Gray |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 18 combined |
| Drivetrain | 4X4 |
$17,490
$17,990
GREAT DEAL
2023 Subaru Crosstrek Sport
- 103,474 Miles
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- Remaining Lifespan: 11.081798 yrs
- $2,663 Below market value of $20,153
- Listed 112 days ago
Additional info close
Used 2023 Subaru Crosstrek Sport for Sale
103,474 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $17,490 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2GTHRC4PH223270 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 103,474 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Magnetite gray metallic |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$19,990
GOOD DEAL
2020 Subaru Crosstrek Premium
- 49,533 Miles
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- Remaining Lifespan: 9.000068 yrs
- $443 Below market value of $20,433
- Listed 9 days ago
Additional info close
Used 2020 Subaru Crosstrek Premium for Sale
49,533 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $19,990 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2GTAPC1LH256263 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 49,533 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Crystal white pearl |
| MPG | 30 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$23,000
$23,200
GOOD DEAL
2023 Hyundai Ioniq 6 SEL
- 15,446 Miles
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $2,146 Below market value of $25,146
- Low annual miles
- Listed 63 days ago
Additional info close
Used 2023 Hyundai Ioniq 6 SEL for Sale
15,446 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $23,000 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Fuel Type | Electric |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | KMHM34AC7PA051780 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, navigation, backup camera, internet radio |
| Mileage | 15,446 mi. |
| Transmission | Automatic |
| Exterior Color | Blue |
| Interior Color | Gray |
| MPG | 121 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$14,529
$14,809
GOOD DEAL
2019 Cadillac XT5 Luxury
- 102,072 Miles
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $1,287 Below market value of $15,816
- 4 Price Drops in 22 days
- Listed 21 days ago
Additional info close
Used 2019 Cadillac XT5 Luxury for Sale
102,072 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $14,529 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 6-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 1GYKNDRS1KZ130383 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, leather upholstery, sunroof |
| Mileage | 102,072 mi. |
| Transmission | Automatic |
| Exterior Color | Gray |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 21 combined |
| Drivetrain | 4X4 |
$32,107
$35,034
GOOD DEAL
2025 Ford Bronco Sport Badlands
- 15,857 Miles
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $3,391 Below market value of $35,498
- 6 Price Drops in 46 days
- Listed 45 days ago
Additional info close
Used 2025 Ford Bronco Sport Badlands for Sale
15,857 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $32,107 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 3FMCR9DA9SRE46463 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, alloy wheels, satellite radio |
| Mileage | 15,857 mi. |
| Transmission | Automatic |
| Exterior Color | Black |
| Interior Color | Gray |
| MPG | 23 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$32,081
$32,408
GOOD DEAL
2021 Toyota Tundra SR5
- 98,509 Miles
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- Remaining Lifespan: 10.854589 yrs
- $3,524 Below market value of $35,605
- Listed 42 days ago
Additional info close
Used 2021 Toyota Tundra SR5 for Sale
98,509 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $32,081 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 8-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 6 Seats |
| VIN | 5TFDY5F10MX975585 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, satellite radio, voice recognition |
| Mileage | 98,509 mi. |
| Transmission | Automatic |
| Exterior Color | Red |
| Interior Color | Gray |
| MPG | 14 combined |
| Drivetrain | 4X4 |
$25,490
$27,490
GOOD DEAL
2023 Subaru Crosstrek Limited
- 16,434 Miles
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- Remaining Lifespan: 11.075344 yrs
- $1,067 Below market value of $26,557
- Listed 105 days ago
Additional info close
Used 2023 Subaru Crosstrek Limited for Sale
16,434 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $25,490 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2GTHNCXPH259437 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, leather upholstery, internet radio |
| Mileage | 16,434 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Crystal white pearl |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$17,990
GOOD DEAL
2020 Subaru Outback Limited
- 100,391 Miles
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $1,376 Below market value of $19,366
- 1 Owner
- Listed 26 days ago
Additional info close
Used 2020 Subaru Outback Limited for Sale
100,391 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $17,990 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 4S4BTANC2L3133401 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, leather upholstery, internet radio |
| Mileage | 100,391 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Crystal black silica |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$17,490
$20,490
GOOD DEAL
2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium
- 49,059 Miles
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- Remaining Lifespan: 5.741925 yrs
- $1,330 Below market value of $18,820
- Listed 91 days ago
Additional info close
Used 2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium for Sale
49,059 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $17,490 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2SJAEC7JH450957 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, sunroof |
| Mileage | 49,059 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Crystal black silica |
| Interior Color | Black |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$20,490
$21,990
GOOD DEAL
2021 Subaru Ascent Limited 8-Passenger
- 92,912 Miles
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $1,629 Below market value of $22,119
- 1 Owner
- Listed 73 days ago
Additional info close
Used 2021 Subaru Ascent Limited 8-Passenger for Sale
92,912 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $20,490 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 8 Seats |
| VIN | 4S4WMAJD6M3406404 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, leather upholstery, internet radio |
| Mileage | 92,912 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Brilliant bronze metallic |
| MPG | 22 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$20,694
$20,926
GOOD DEAL
2023 Dodge Hornet GT
- 12,063 Miles
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- $483 Below market value of $21,177
- Low annual miles
- Listed 59 days ago
Additional info close
Used 2023 Dodge Hornet GT for Sale
12,063 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $20,694 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | ZACNDFAN4P3A03616 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, alloy wheels, satellite radio |
| Mileage | 12,063 mi. |
| Transmission | Automatic |
| Exterior Color | Red |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 24 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$21,000
$21,200
GOOD DEAL
2022 Jeep Compass Limited
- 39,062 Miles
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- Remaining Lifespan: 9.001224 yrs
- $574 Below market value of $21,574
- Listed 63 days ago
Additional info close
Used 2022 Jeep Compass Limited for Sale
39,062 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $21,000 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 3C4NJDCBXNT186857 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, leather upholstery, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 39,062 mi. |
| Transmission | Automatic |
| Exterior Color | Red |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 25 combined |
| Drivetrain | 4X4 |
$20,990
$22,990
GOOD DEAL
2020 Subaru Forester Sport
- 70,441 Miles
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- Remaining Lifespan: 9.268071 yrs
- $557 Below market value of $21,547
- Listed 165 days ago
Additional info close
Used 2020 Subaru Forester Sport for Sale
70,441 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $20,990 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2SKAMC1LH579682 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, sunroof |
| Mileage | 70,441 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Crystal black silica |
| Interior Color | Gray |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$16,990
$18,990
GOOD DEAL
2021 Subaru Crosstrek Premium
- 80,268 Miles
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- Remaining Lifespan: 9.596425 yrs
- $1,604 Below market value of $18,594
- Listed 144 days ago
Additional info close
Used 2021 Subaru Crosstrek Premium for Sale
80,268 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $16,990 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2GTAPC3MH385381 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 80,268 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Crystal white pearl |
| MPG | 30 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$26,490
FAIR DEAL
2023 Subaru Crosstrek Limited
- 13,909 Miles
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- Remaining Lifespan: 11.088251 yrs
- $262 Above market value of $26,752
- Listed 34 days ago
Additional info close
Used 2023 Subaru Crosstrek Limited for Sale
13,909 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Certified Used Cars |
| Price | $26,490 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2GTHMC8PH279624 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, leather upholstery, internet radio |
| Mileage | 13,909 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Cool gray khaki |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$26,990
FAIR DEAL
2023 Subaru Forester Sport
- 24,531 Miles
- Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
- Remaining Lifespan: 11.277938 yrs
- $18 Above market value of $26,972
- Listed 47 days ago
Additional info close
Used 2023 Subaru Forester Sport for Sale
24,531 Miles
Middletown, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Certified Used Cars |
| Price | $26,990 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2SKAGC1PH499641 |
| Location | Middletown, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, sunroof |
| Mileage | 24,531 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Sapphire blue pearl |
| Interior Color | Gray |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
Page 1 of 17
Other Nearby Dealers
Used Cars for Sale Insights
Find More Cars For Sale
Explore Models
Nissan Altima
Save $6,043 on 9,110 Deals
27,285 Listings from $1,000
27,285 Listings from $1,000
Toyota Camry
Save $8,728 on 11,656 Deals
38,436 Listings from $975
38,436 Listings from $975
Toyota Corolla
Save $6,718 on 8,204 Deals
25,524 Listings from $997
25,524 Listings from $997
Chrysler Town and Country
Save $4,247 on 669 Deals
1,825 Listings from $950
1,825 Listings from $950
Ram Ram Pickup 1500
Save $25,795 on 17,765 Deals
80,864 Listings from $2,900
80,864 Listings from $2,900
Toyota Tacoma
Save $11,185 on 8,391 Deals
46,497 Listings from $2,995
46,497 Listings from $2,995
Ford Super Duty F-250
Save $16,831 on 5,195 Deals
42,367 Listings from $2,500
42,367 Listings from $2,500
Chevrolet Traverse
Save $10,535 on 8,771 Deals
29,991 Listings from $1,781
29,991 Listings from $1,781
Jeep Liberty
Save $2,887 on 279 Deals
836 Listings from $1,199
836 Listings from $1,199
BMW X5
Save $14,770 on 5,105 Deals
17,833 Listings from $2,500
17,833 Listings from $2,500