Used Toyota Highlander for Sale in New York, NY

There are 779 used Toyota Highlander for sale in New York, NY with an average price of $28,562. Of those, 232 are priced below market value with each Toyota Highlander in New York averaging $1,952 below market value.
1-19 of 779 Cars Found
Save Search
2021 Toyota Highlander XSE

2021 Toyota Highlander XSE - 45,322 mi

Little Falls, NJ (14 mi) - Listed 54 days ago
  • $4,259 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner, certified used, 4 positives , low annual miles
$32,628
PREVIEW
iSeeCars Unbiased Insights

How can you save money on a used Toyota Highlander?

  • Highlander

    $36,623
    $6,873 Savings

    Highlander Hybrid

    $43,496
  • 4-Cylinder

    $27,364
    $5,231 Savings

    6-Cylinder

    $32,594
  • FWD

    $36,588
    $336 Savings

    AWD

    $36,924

iSeeCars analyzes over 25 billion data points to help you find the best deals.
See more ways to save.

iSeeCars Unbiased Insights

Does car color affect the price of a used Toyota Highlander?

Least
Expensive

Gold

$3,004Average Savings

Most
Expensive

Beige

$7,220Average Premium

iSeeCars analyzes over 25 billion data points to help you find the best deals.
See more ways to save.

View on dealer site
2012 Toyota Highlander Sport Utility 4D

2012 Toyota Highlander Sport Utili - 178,373 mi

West Milford, NJ (31 mi) - Listed 123 days ago
  • $1,565 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • certified used
$8,899
PREVIEW
2005 Toyota Highlander V6

2005 Toyota Highlander V6 - 162,270 mi

Carlstadt, NJ (5 mi) - Listed 9 days ago
  • $1,684 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner
PREVIEW
2019 Toyota Highlander LE

2019 Toyota Highlander LE - 52,723 mi

Eatontown, NJ (31 mi) - Listed 65 days ago
  • $3,042 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner, 1 positive , low annual miles
$24,125
PREVIEW
2022 Toyota Highlander XLE

2022 Toyota Highlander XLE - 28,338 mi

Freeport, NY (22 mi) - Listed 2 days ago
  • $3,630 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner, low annual miles
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2008 Toyota Highlander Sport

2008 Toyota Highlander Sport - 191,501 mi

Roselle, NJ (15 mi) - Listed 4 days ago
  • $2,182 below market price
  • dealer rating
PREVIEW
2005 Toyota Highlander Base

2005 Toyota Highlander Base - 63,275 mi

Ramsey, NJ (23 mi) - Listed 1 day ago
  • $2,169 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 2 positives , low annual miles
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2014 Toyota Highlander XLE

2014 Toyota Highlander XLE - 137,348 mi

Elizabeth, NJ (13 mi) - Listed 93 days ago
  • $3,616 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner
$13,495
PREVIEW
2017 Toyota Highlander XLE

2017 Toyota Highlander XLE - 102,230 mi

Long Island City, NY (2 mi) - Listed 2 days ago
  • $5,426 below market price
  • dealer rating
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2005 Toyota Highlander Base

2005 Toyota Highlander Base - 158,021 mi

Hasbrouck Heights, NJ (8 mi) - Listed 7 days ago
  • $1,466 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1 price drop in 8 days
$5,495
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2015 Toyota Highlander XLE

2015 Toyota Highlander XLE - 137,900 mi

Bloomfield, NJ (11 mi) - Listed 12 days ago
  • $3,481 below market price
  • dealer rating
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2003 Toyota Highlander Sport Utility 4D

2003 Toyota Highlander Sport Utili - 131,699 mi

Belleville, NJ (9 mi) - Listed 123 days ago
  • $2,224 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 4 price drops in 124 days
$4,999
PREVIEW
2023 Toyota Highlander L

2023 Toyota Highlander L - 29,974 mi

Valley Stream, NY - Listed 13 days ago
  • $3,986 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner, 2 positives
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2009 Toyota Highlander Limited

2009 Toyota Highlander Limited - 163,465 mi

Bloomfield, NJ (11 mi) - Listed 111 days ago
  • $2,490 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 3 price drops in 112 days
$10,222
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2019 Toyota Highlander XLE

2019 Toyota Highlander XLE - 52,736 mi

Butler, NJ (27 mi) - Listed 13 days ago
  • $3,858 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner, low annual miles
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2010 Toyota Highlander Base

2010 Toyota Highlander Base - 130,930 mi

Hasbrouck Heights, NJ (8 mi) - Listed 6 days ago
  • $1,392 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1 price drop in 7 days
$10,099
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2008 Toyota Highlander Base

2008 Toyota Highlander Base - 80,505 mi

South Hackensack, NJ (8 mi) - Listed 16 days ago
  • $1,947 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • low annual miles
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2019 Toyota Highlander XLE

2019 Toyota Highlander XLE - 56,666 mi

Newark, NJ (11 mi) - Listed 15 days ago
  • $3,145 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner, low annual miles
$25,657
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2006 Toyota Highlander Limited

2006 Toyota Highlander Limited - 176,852 mi

Clifton, NJ (12 mi) - Listed 25 days ago
  • $1,594 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1 price drop in 26 days
$5,699
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2008 Toyota Highlander Limited

2008 Toyota Highlander Limited - 150,729 mi

Paterson, NJ (14 mi) - Listed 6 days ago
  • $1,473 below market price
  • dealer rating
PREVIEW
X
Would you like to view the latest search results ?
Yes     No
Zip Code Required X

Please enter a five-digit zip code to find cars for sale near you.

Used Toyota Highlander Pricing in New York

Average Price
$28,562
For a used Toyota Highlander
Average Savings
$1,952
Based on all Highlander deals found
Biggest Savings
$5,426
Below estimated market price
Good Deal
$25,598
Typical price of a good deal

How to save money when buying a used Toyota Highlander in New York?

Fuel Type A Highlander averages $6,873 less than a Highlander Hybrid
Engine A 4-Cylinder Highlander costs $5,231 less than a 6-Cylinder
Drive Type A front-wheel drive (FWD) Toyota Highlander can be priced $336 less than an all-wheel drive (AWD)

Buying Tips

Average car color pricing for a used Toyota Highlander in New York?

Rank Color Compared to Avg Price
1 Gold $3,004 Savings
2 Brown $1,856 Savings
3 Purple $1,841 Savings
4 Black $934 Savings
5 Silver $503 Savings
6 Gray $468 Savings
7 Orange $134 Savings
8 Red $147 Higher
9 White $193 Higher
10 Green $479 Higher
11 Blue $735 Higher
12 Beige $7,220 Higher

What Toyota Highlander color has the best resale value in New York?

Price differences by car color compared to the average price of a used Toyota Highlander in New York

What is the best time to buy a used Toyota Highlander in New York?

Good times to buy
- Save $274 on average: January, September, October, November, December are good times to buy to find the best prices.
Good times to sell
- Make an extra $198 on average: February, March, April, May, June, July, August are good times to sell to get the best prices

What is the average price for Used Toyota Highlander for Sale in New York, NY? How many are for sale and priced below market?

  • 779 cars for sale found, starting at $3,240
  • Average price for Used Toyota Highlander New York, NY: $28,562
  • 232 deals found. Average savings of $1,952
  • Save up to $5,426 below estimated market price
Search for a used Toyota Highlander in New York
See my listings

What colors are the best deals for a Toyota Highlander in New York?

Least Expensive Color
Gold $3,004Average Savings
Most Expensive Color
Beige $7,220Average Premium
Total saved by iSeeCars users

$418,837,512

Start searching smarter now

Similar Models

Average Price Deals Listings
BMW X1 for Sale $35,982 Save $9,375 on 898 deals 3,606 listings
Chevrolet Traverse for Sale $30,624 Save $9,948 on 2,714 deals 10,599 listings
Dodge Durango for Sale $47,183 Save $14,318 on 2,904 deals 13,553 listings
Ford Explorer for Sale $36,692 Save $10,673 on 7,093 deals 33,853 listings
Honda Pilot for Sale $39,101 Save $7,967 on 2,641 deals 17,734 listings
Hyundai Santa Fe for Sale $37,715 Save $9,355 on 2,610 deals 20,759 listings
Jeep Grand Cherokee for Sale $41,590 Save $12,417 on 7,932 deals 36,274 listings
Mazda CX-9 for Sale $24,555 Save $6,683 on 1,064 deals 2,382 listings
Nissan Murano for Sale $32,634 Save $8,102 on 2,049 deals 9,215 listings
Nissan Pathfinder for Sale $39,604 Save $7,515 on 2,152 deals 13,733 listings

Popular Toyota Models

Average Price Deals Listings
Toyota 4runner for Sale $37,624 Save $7,140 on 1,447 deals 8,590 listings
Toyota Camry for Sale $24,539 Save $5,852 on 3,303 deals 19,333 listings
Toyota Corolla for Sale $19,023 Save $5,134 on 2,912 deals 13,311 listings
Toyota Tacoma for Sale $39,061 Save $11,769 on 3,856 deals 25,018 listings
Toyota Tundra for Sale $55,485 Save $14,516 on 2,398 deals 19,031 listings

Explore other cities

Average Price Deals Listings
Toyota Highlander in Jersey City $28,907 Save $5,022 on 254 deals 854 listings
Toyota Highlander in Philadelphia $29,640 Save $4,512 on 109 deals 398 listings
Toyota Highlander in Springfield $26,265 Save $5,082 on 64 deals 186 listings
Toyota Highlander in Providence $26,848 Save $4,700 on 79 deals 289 listings
Toyota Highlander in Baltimore $29,436 Save $5,278 on 174 deals 576 listings
Toyota Highlander in Syracuse $28,723 Save $3,200 on 21 deals 59 listings
Toyota Highlander in Boston $27,277 Save $4,700 on 94 deals 359 listings

Average Price of Used Toyota Highlander for Sale in New York, NY Trims

Trim Average Price Listings Specs
Used Toyota Highlander for Sale in New York, NY XLE
(2014-2020)
$30,561 4,208 Listings
Body Style SUV
Drive Train AWD, FWD
Fuel Type Gas
Features see features...
Used Toyota Highlander for Sale in New York, NY Limited
(2002-2020)
$23,067 1,707 Listings
Body Style SUV
Drive Train AWD, FWD
Fuel Type Gas
Features see features...
Used Toyota Highlander for Sale in New York, NY LE
(2014-2020)
$27,694 1,212 Listings
Body Style SUV
Drive Train AWD, FWD
Fuel Type Gas
Features see features...
Used Toyota Highlander for Sale in New York, NY SE
(2010-2013, 2017-2019)
$17,939 541 Listings
Body Style SUV
Drive Train AWD, FWD
Fuel Type Gas
Features see features...
Used Toyota Highlander for Sale in New York, NY Base
(2001-2013)
$9,634 526 Listings
Body Style SUV
Drive Train AWD, FWD
Fuel Type Gas
Features see features...
Used Toyota Highlander for Sale in New York, NY XSE
(2021)
$37,634 508 Listings
Body Style SUV
Drive Train AWD, FWD
Fuel Type Gas
Used Toyota Highlander for Sale in New York, NY L
(2020)
$32,412 429 Listings
Body Style SUV
Drive Train AWD, FWD
Fuel Type Gas
Features see features...
Used Toyota Highlander for Sale in New York, NY Platinum
(2020)
$40,703 410 Listings
Body Style SUV
Drive Train AWD, FWD
Fuel Type Gas
Features see features...
Used Toyota Highlander for Sale in New York, NY Limited Platinum
(2014-2020)
$25,898 205 Listings
Body Style SUV
Drive Train AWD, FWD
Fuel Type Gas
Features see features...
Used Toyota Highlander for Sale in New York, NY LE Plus
(2014-2019)
$21,291 179 Listings
Body Style SUV
Drive Train AWD, FWD
Fuel Type Gas
Features see features...
Keep me posted on new listings X
Do you have a price in mind?
Let us know and we can send you better matches.
By clicking "Subscribe" you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.
Save This Car X
GET ALERTS
By clicking "Start Tracking" you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.
Save This Search X
Be the first to see new listings
and price drops for your search.
GET ALERTS
By clicking "Get Alerts" you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.