Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY

There are 1,277 used Subaru Forester for sale in New York, NY with an average price of $28,327. Of those, 228 are priced below market value with each Subaru Forester in New York averaging $1,459 below market value.
1-20 of 1,277 Cars Found
Save Search
View on dealer site
2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium - 74,189 mi

Carlstadt, NJ (5 mi) - Listed 42 days ago
  • $1,714 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • certified used, low annual miles
$14,595
PREVIEW
2014 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

2014 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium - 34,342 mi

Keyport, NJ (22 mi) - Listed 44 days ago
  • $2,250 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner, 2 positives , low annual miles
PREVIEW
iSeeCars Unbiased Insights

Does car color affect the price of a used Subaru Forester?

Least
Expensive

Gray

$541Average Savings

Most
Expensive

Gold

$1,536Average Premium

iSeeCars analyzes over 25 billion data points to help you find the best deals.
See more ways to save.

2021 Subaru Forester Limited

2021 Subaru Forester Limited - 9,660 mi

Great Neck, NY (13 mi) - Listed 5 days ago
  • $5,860 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner, 1 positive , low annual miles
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2020 Subaru Forester Touring

2020 Subaru Forester Touring - 59,854 mi

Bronx, NY (12 mi) - Listed 5 days ago
  • $4,716 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • low annual miles
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2011 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium

2011 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium - 95,786 mi

East Brunswick, NJ (31 mi) - Listed 117 days ago
  • $2,964 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • low annual miles
PREVIEW
2012 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium

2012 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium - 50,291 mi

West Nyack, NY (24 mi) - Listed 7 days ago
  • $1,850 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner, 1 positive , low annual miles
PREVIEW
View on partner site
2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i

2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i - 98,006 mi

Elmwood Park, NJ (12 mi) - Listed 34 days ago
  • $2,744 below market price
  • 1-owner
  • 5 price drops in 35 days
$11,867
PREVIEW
2020 Subaru Forester Touring

2020 Subaru Forester Touring - 56,475 mi

Freeport, NY (22 mi) - Listed 76 days ago
  • $3,010 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • low annual miles
$22,326
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2012 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium

2012 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium - 81,050 mi

Bohemia, NY (44 mi) - Listed 12 days ago
  • $3,047 below market price
  • low annual miles
PREVIEW
2021 Subaru Forester Base

2021 Subaru Forester Base - 21,677 mi

Syosset, NY (25 mi) - Listed 83 days ago
  • $3,650 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner, 1 positive , low annual miles
$20,195
PREVIEW
2019 Subaru Forester Touring

2019 Subaru Forester Touring - 44,179 mi

Farmingdale, NJ (38 mi) - Listed 22 days ago
  • $3,101 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner, 2 positives , low annual miles
PREVIEW
2021 Subaru Forester Premium

2021 Subaru Forester Premium - 16,000 mi

South Amboy, NJ (24 mi) - Listed 72 days ago
  • $3,492 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner, low annual miles
$22,444
PREVIEW
2023 Subaru Forester Wilderness

2023 Subaru Forester Wilderness - 4,673 mi

Ramsey, NJ - Listed 140 days ago
  • $1,627 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner, certified used, 5 positives , low annual miles
$31,940
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2012 Subaru Forester 2.5X

2012 Subaru Forester 2.5X - 113,420 mi

Garfield, NJ (11 mi) - Listed 5 days ago
  • $1,090 below market price
  • dealer rating
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2011 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium

2011 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium - 128,425 mi

South Hackensack, NJ (8 mi) - Listed 17 days ago
  • $1,277 below market price
  • dealer rating
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2012 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium

2012 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium - 144,692 mi

Irvington, NJ (12 mi) - Listed 19 days ago
  • $1,187 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 2 price drops in 20 days
$7,500
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2009 Subaru Forester 2.5 X Premium

2009 Subaru Forester 2.5 X Premium - 162,497 mi

Middle Village, NY (6 mi) - Listed 22 days ago
  • $1,581 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1 price drop in 23 days
$4,995
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2009 Subaru Forester 2.5 X

2009 Subaru Forester 2.5 X - 120,000 mi

Lawrence, NY (17 mi) - Listed 1 day ago
  • $1,203 below market price
  • dealer rating
PREVIEW
2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium - 120,439 mi

Lyndhurst, NJ (8 mi) - Listed 7 days ago
  • $1,629 below market price
  • dealer rating
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited

2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited - 82,390 mi

Little Ferry, NJ (7 mi) - Listed 37 days ago
  • $1,621 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • low annual miles
$13,499
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited

2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited - 90,638 mi

Bronx, NY (12 mi) - Listed 52 days ago
  • $2,130 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • low annual miles
$15,495
PREVIEW
X
Would you like to view the latest search results ?
Yes     No
Zip Code Required X

Please enter a five-digit zip code to find cars for sale near you.

Used Subaru Forester Pricing in New York

Average Price
$28,327
For a used Subaru Forester
Average Savings
$1,459
Based on all Forester deals found
Biggest Savings
$5,860
Below estimated market price
Good Deal
$19,306
Typical price of a good deal

Buying Tips

Average car color pricing for a used Subaru Forester in New York?

Rank Color Compared to Avg Price
1 Gray $541 Savings
2 Brown $396 Savings
3 Black $192 Savings
4 White $123 Savings
5 Silver $104 Savings
6 Red $53 Higher
7 Blue $669 Higher
8 Green $865 Higher
9 Gold $1,536 Higher

What Subaru Forester color has the best resale value in New York?

Price differences by car color compared to the average price of a used Subaru Forester in New York

What is the best time to buy a used Subaru Forester in New York?

Good times to buy
- Save $184 on average: January, August, September, October, November, December are good times to buy to find the best prices.
Good times to sell
- Make an extra $193 on average: February, March, April, May, June, July are good times to sell to get the best prices

What is the average price for Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY? How many are for sale and priced below market?

  • 1,277 cars for sale found, starting at $2,995
  • Average price for Used Subaru Forester New York, NY: $28,327
  • 228 deals found. Average savings of $1,459
  • Save up to $5,860 below estimated market price
Search for a used Subaru Forester in New York
See my listings

What colors are the best deals for a Subaru Forester in New York?

Least Expensive Color
Gray $541Average Savings
Most Expensive Color
Gold $1,536Average Premium
Total saved by iSeeCars users

$418,837,512

Start searching smarter now

Similar Models

Average Price Deals Listings
Mini Countryman for Sale $30,337 Save $6,618 on 487 deals 2,178 listings
Mitsubishi Outlander Sport for Sale $21,212 Save $5,020 on 678 deals 2,832 listings
Nissan Juke for Sale $9,977 Save $4,113 on 254 deals 570 listings
Nissan Rogue Select for Sale $9,422 Save $4,507 on 111 deals 303 listings
Nissan Rogue for Sale $30,992 Save $6,699 on 5,886 deals 40,845 listings
Scion XB for Sale $7,921 Save $3,318 on 104 deals 307 listings
Subaru Impreza for Sale $20,358 Save $5,314 on 935 deals 4,408 listings
Subaru Outback for Sale $32,992 Save $8,416 on 3,161 deals 21,109 listings
Subaru XV Crosstrek for Sale $30,234 Save $7,909 on 1,614 deals 16,646 listings
Volkswagen Golf Sportwagen for Sale $15,068 Save $5,234 on 75 deals 221 listings

Popular Subaru Models

Average Price Deals Listings
Subaru BRZ for Sale $28,241 Save $5,155 on 99 deals 454 listings
Subaru Forester for Sale $28,335 Save $8,677 on 2,636 deals 12,877 listings
Subaru WRX for Sale $32,536 Save $9,172 on 588 deals 4,209 listings

Explore other cities

Average Price Deals Listings
Subaru Forester in Springfield $25,531 Save $3,512 on 97 deals 447 listings
Subaru Forester in Manchester $28,190 Save $3,173 on 82 deals 591 listings

Average Price of Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY Trims

Trim Average Price Listings Specs
Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY Premium
(2019-2020)
$23,999 1,229 Listings
Body Style Wagon
Drive Train AWD
Fuel Type Gas
Features see features...
Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY 2.5i Premium
(2014-2018)
$14,388 1,176 Listings
Body Style Wagon
Drive Train AWD
Fuel Type Gas
Features see features...
Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY Limited
(2019-2020)
$27,529 758 Listings
Body Style Wagon
Drive Train AWD
Fuel Type Gas
Features see features...
Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY Sport
(2019-2020)
$26,490 702 Listings
Body Style Wagon
Drive Train AWD
Fuel Type Gas
Features see features...
Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY 2.5i Limited
(2014-2018)
$14,686 606 Listings
Body Style Wagon
Drive Train AWD
Fuel Type Gas
Features see features...
Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY Touring
(2019-2020)
$29,301 578 Listings
Body Style Wagon
Drive Train AWD
Fuel Type Gas
Features see features...
Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY 2.5i
(2014-2018)
$13,381 493 Listings
Body Style Wagon
Drive Train AWD
Fuel Type Gas
Features see features...
Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY Base
(1998-1999, 2019-2020)
$21,143 420 Listings
Body Style Wagon
Drive Train AWD
Fuel Type Gas
Features see features...
Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY 2.5X Premium
(2010-2013)
$9,214 400 Listings
Body Style Wagon
Drive Train AWD
Fuel Type Gas
Features see features...
Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY 2.5X
(2010-2013)
$9,164 295 Listings
Body Style Wagon
Drive Train AWD
Fuel Type Gas
Features see features...
Keep me posted on new listings X
Do you have a price in mind?
Let us know and we can send you better matches.
By clicking "Subscribe" you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.
Save This Car X
GET ALERTS
By clicking "Start Tracking" you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.
Save This Search X
Be the first to see new listings
and price drops for your search.
GET ALERTS
By clicking "Get Alerts" you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.