Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY

1-20 of 584 Cars Found
Save Search
X

Message:

2009 Subaru Forester 2.5 X Limited

2009 Subaru Forester 2.5 X Limited - 127,055 mi

East Meadow, NY (22 mi) - Listed 137 days ago
  • $3,307 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 8 price drops in 138 days
$5,496
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2012 Subaru Forester 2.5X Touring

2012 Subaru Forester 2.5X Touring - 124,395 mi

Little Ferry, NJ (7 mi) - Listed 68 days ago
  • $1,460 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 5 price drops in 69 days
$9,750
PREVIEW
iSeeCars Unbiased Insights

How can you save money on a used Subaru Forester?

  • Manual

    $24,009
    $1,580 Savings

    Automatic

    $25,589

iSeeCars analyzes over 25 billion data points to help you find the best deals.
See more ways to save.

iSeeCars Unbiased Insights

Does car color affect the price of a used Subaru Forester?

Least
Expensive

Green

$420Average Savings

Most
Expensive

Beige

$2,243Average Premium

iSeeCars analyzes over 25 billion data points to help you find the best deals.
See more ways to save.

View on dealer site
2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium - 148,960 mi

Monroe Township, NJ (37 mi) - Listed 45 days ago
  • $1,853 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • high annual miles
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2004 Subaru Forester XS

2004 Subaru Forester XS - 92,326 mi

Lakewood, NJ (47 mi) - Listed 17 days ago
  • $2,135 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • low annual miles
PREVIEW
2020 Subaru Forester Premium

2020 Subaru Forester Premium - 12,970 mi

West Islip, NY (36 mi) - Listed 5 days ago
  • $2,958 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner, low annual miles
PREVIEW
View on partner site
2020 Subaru Forester Touring

2020 Subaru Forester Touring - 37,022 mi

Roslyn, NY (18 mi) - Listed 10 days ago
  • $3,451 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • low annual miles
$28,495
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2003 Subaru Forester XS

2003 Subaru Forester XS - 220,224 mi

Lakewood, NJ (47 mi) - Listed 202 days ago
  • $688 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 2 price drops in 203 days
$3,699
PREVIEW
2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium - 113,172 mi

Hillside, NJ (12 mi) - Listed 11 days ago
  • $2,430 below market price
  • 1-owner, high annual miles
  • 1 price drop in 12 days
$15,999
PREVIEW
Home Delivery
2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium - 86,114 mi

Union, NJ (14 mi) - Listed today
  • $2,137 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • low annual miles
$15,099
PREVIEW
2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium - 186,186 mi

Peekskill, NY (37 mi) - Listed 29 days ago
  • $1,346 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner, high annual miles
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium - 155,354 mi

South Hackensack, NJ (8 mi) - Listed 159 days ago
  • $1,463 below market price
  • dealer rating
PREVIEW
2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium - 115,625 mi

Hillside, NJ (12 mi) - Listed 23 days ago
  • $2,098 below market price
  • 1-owner
  • 1 price drop in 24 days
$14,990
PREVIEW
View on dealer site
2013 Subaru Forester 2.5X

2013 Subaru Forester 2.5X - 190,335 mi

South Hackensack, NJ (8 mi) - Listed 143 days ago
  • $717 below market price
  • dealer rating
PREVIEW
View on partner site
2020 Subaru Forester Limited

2020 Subaru Forester Limited - 27,819 mi

Roslyn, NY (18 mi) - Listed 79 days ago
  • $3,137 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • low annual miles
$28,005
PREVIEW
View on partner site
2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i

2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i - 184,000 mi

North Bergen, NJ (4 mi) - Listed 25 days ago
  • $1,768 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • high annual miles
PREVIEW
View on partner site
2015 Subaru Forester 2.0XT Premium

2015 Subaru Forester 2.0XT Premium - 141,415 mi

Franklin, NJ (40 mi) - Listed 107 days ago
  • $1,608 below market price
  • 1-owner
  • 2 price drops in 108 days
$11,499
PREVIEW
2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium - 81,448 mi

East Meadow, NY (22 mi) - Listed 120 days ago
  • $2,863 below market price
  • dealer rating
PREVIEW
Home Delivery
2022 Subaru Forester Wilderness

2022 Subaru Forester Wilderness - 2,208 mi

Ramsey, NJ (23 mi) - Listed 6 days ago
  • $2,150 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner, low annual miles
PREVIEW
2020 Subaru Forester Limited

2020 Subaru Forester Limited - 13,890 mi

Brooklyn, NY (9 mi) - Listed 29 days ago
  • $2,884 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner, low annual miles
$27,995
PREVIEW
2020 Subaru Forester Base

2020 Subaru Forester Base - 5,261 mi

Jersey City, NJ (6 mi) - Listed 1 day ago
  • $1,350 below market price
  • dealer rating
  • 1-owner, low annual miles
PREVIEW
X
Would you like to view the latest search results ?
Yes     No
Zip Code Required X

Please enter a five-digit zip code to find cars for sale near you.

Used Subaru Forester Pricing in New York

Average Price
$23,895
For a used Subaru Forester
Average Savings
$1,407
Based on all Forester deals found
Biggest Savings
$3,451
Below estimated market price
Good Deal
$20,192
Typical price of a good deal

How to save money when buying a used Subaru Forester in New York?

Transmission Buying a Subaru Forester with stick shift instead of a automatic transmission can save you $1,580

Buying Tips

Average car color pricing for a used Subaru Forester in New York?

Rank Color Compared to Avg Price
1 Green $420 Savings
2 Silver $341 Savings
3 Red $279 Savings
4 Gray $198 Savings
5 Black $63 Higher
6 Blue $330 Higher
7 White $447 Higher
8 Gold $682 Higher
9 Brown $1,019 Higher
10 Beige $2,243 Higher

What Subaru Forester color has the best resale value in New York?

Price differences by car color compared to the average price of a used Subaru Forester in New York

What is the best time to buy a used Subaru Forester in New York?

Good times to buy
- Save $184 on average: January, August, September, October, November, December are good times to buy to find the best prices.
Good times to sell
- Make an extra $193 on average: February, March, April, May, June, July are good times to sell to get the best prices

What is the average price for Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY? How many are for sale and priced below market?

  • 584 cars for sale found, starting at $2,990
  • Average price for Used Subaru Forester New York, NY: $23,895
  • 143 deals found. Average savings of $1,407
  • Save up to $3,451 below estimated market price
Search for a used Subaru Forester in New York
See my listings

What colors are the best deals for a Subaru Forester in New York?

Least Expensive Color
Green $420Average Savings
Most Expensive Color
Beige $2,243Average Premium
Total saved by iSeeCars users

$386,182,499

Start searching smarter now

Price of Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY by Distance

Distance from New York, NY Average Price Deals Listings
50 miles
$23,918 Save $5,083 on 147 deals 594 listings
100 miles
$23,451 Save $6,910 on 502 deals 1,256 listings

Similar Models

Average Price Deals Listings
Mini Countryman for Sale $23,759 Save $6,970 on 372 deals 1,117 listings
Mitsubishi Outlander Sport for Sale $19,025 Save $5,059 on 549 deals 2,067 listings
Nissan Juke for Sale $11,789 Save $4,294 on 269 deals 686 listings
Nissan Rogue Select for Sale $11,515 Save $4,026 on 115 deals 294 listings
Nissan Rogue for Sale $23,935 Save $6,272 on 2,967 deals 14,838 listings
Scion XB for Sale $9,194 Save $3,215 on 93 deals 353 listings
Subaru Impreza for Sale $17,326 Save $6,456 on 819 deals 2,789 listings
Subaru Outback for Sale $27,102 Save $8,753 on 1,575 deals 7,939 listings
Subaru XV Crosstrek for Sale $24,483 Save $6,881 on 735 deals 3,783 listings
Volkswagen Golf Sportwagen for Sale $17,153 Save $4,633 on 59 deals 212 listings

Used Subaru Forester By Model Year

Year Average Price Deals Listings
2023 Subaru Forester in New York
$37,076 - 172 listings
2022 Subaru Forester in New York
$34,592 Save $3,173 on 47 deals 75 listings
2020 Subaru Forester in New York
$27,216 Save $3,301 on 58 deals 123 listings
2019 Subaru Forester in New York
$25,398 Save $4,160 on 40 deals 62 listings
2017 Subaru Forester in New York
$19,467 Save $3,728 on 15 deals 32 listings

Popular Subaru Models

Average Price Deals Listings
Subaru BRZ for Sale $25,408 Save $6,036 on 55 deals 233 listings
Subaru Forester for Sale $22,184 Save $8,462 on 1,340 deals 5,617 listings
Subaru WRX for Sale $30,657 Save $9,169 on 467 deals 2,054 listings

Explore other cities

Average Price Deals Listings
Subaru Forester in Brooklyn $23,768 Save $4,583 on 147 deals 593 listings
Subaru Forester in Jersey City $23,562 Save $4,583 on 149 deals 584 listings
Subaru Forester in Newark $23,787 Save $4,583 on 153 deals 613 listings
Subaru Forester in Philadelphia $22,865 Save $2,921 on 84 deals 298 listings
Subaru Forester in Springfield $19,040 Save $3,771 on 74 deals 225 listings
Subaru Forester in Albany $20,530 Save $1,906 on 13 deals 42 listings
Subaru Forester in Lancaster $21,967 Save $6,558 on 34 deals 171 listings
Subaru Forester in Providence $20,477 Save $3,574 on 60 deals 174 listings
Subaru Forester in York $23,506 Save $4,368 on 22 deals 137 listings
Subaru Forester in Harrisburg $24,312 Save $4,368 on 13 deals 100 listings
Subaru Forester in Baltimore $22,726 Save $3,066 on 58 deals 253 listings
Subaru Forester in Syracuse $18,620 Save $1,911 on 17 deals 40 listings
Subaru Forester in Cambridge $19,465 Save $3,574 on 69 deals 227 listings
Subaru Forester in Boston $19,437 Save $3,574 on 68 deals 227 listings
Subaru Forester in Manchester $19,330 Save $2,696 on 25 deals 163 listings
Subaru Forester in Washington $21,901 Save $4,011 on 76 deals 283 listings
Subaru Forester in Frederick $23,125 Save $3,066 on 54 deals 239 listings
Subaru Forester in Hagerstown $21,756 Save $2,820 on 24 deals 106 listings
Subaru Forester in Fredericksburg $18,352 Save $4,047 on 65 deals 151 listings
Subaru Forester in Rochester $20,259 Save $2,234 on 13 deals 25 listings

Average Price of Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY Trims

Trim Average Price Listings Specs
Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY 2.5i Premium
(2014-2018)
$17,639 921 Listings
Body Style Wagon
Drive Train AWD
Fuel Type Gasoline
Features see features...
Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY Premium
(2019-2020)
$27,522 828 Listings
Body Style Wagon
Drive Train AWD
Fuel Type Gasoline
Features see features...
Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY Limited
(2019-2020)
$30,657 464 Listings
Body Style Wagon
Drive Train AWD
Fuel Type Gasoline
Features see features...
Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY 2.5i Limited
(2014-2018)
$17,894 433 Listings
Body Style Wagon
Drive Train AWD
Fuel Type Gasoline
Features see features...
Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY Sport
(2019-2020)
$30,195 396 Listings
Body Style Wagon
Drive Train AWD
Fuel Type Gasoline
Features see features...
Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY 2.5X Premium
(2010-2013)
$10,527 381 Listings
Body Style Wagon
Drive Train AWD
Fuel Type Gasoline
Features see features...
Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY 2.5i
(2014-2018)
$15,704 375 Listings
Body Style Wagon
Drive Train AWD
Fuel Type Gasoline
Features see features...
Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY Touring
(2019-2020)
$32,541 319 Listings
Body Style Wagon
Drive Train AWD
Fuel Type Gasoline
Features see features...
Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY 2.5X
(2010-2013)
$10,300 290 Listings
Body Style Wagon
Drive Train AWD
Fuel Type Gasoline
Features see features...
Used Subaru Forester for Sale in New York, NY Base
(1998-1999, 2019-2020)
$24,932 283 Listings
Body Style Wagon
Drive Train AWD
Fuel Type Gasoline
Features see features...
Keep me posted on new listings X
Do you have a price in mind?
Let us know and we can send you better matches.
By clicking "Subscribe" you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.
Save This Car X
GET ALERTS
By clicking "Start Tracking" you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.
Save This Search X
Be the first to see new listings
and price drops for your search.
GET ALERTS
By clicking "Get Alerts" you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.