Competition Subaru of Smithtown in Saint James, NY
Dealer Analysis 16 Deals Found
38 Cars for sale now, starting at $11,499
Avg. Price: 25391.2
Typical Price Range: 17489.8–32437.2
Average Savings ($) Below Market Price
Avg. Savings: $1,428
Save up to $2,491 below est. market price
% of Used Cars That Are Deals
Avg. Mileage: 31153.6
Typical Mileage Range: 3334.8–68669.4
% of Listings with Valid Price, Mileage, and Photo
- This Dealer
- Average Dealer
Competition Subaru of Smithtown is given a 4.0 "overall dealer rating" based on our analysis of 931 cars the dealer recently listed for sale. This assesses the dealer's price competitiveness, responsiveness to inquiries, and information transparency (how good the dealers are at providing basic information such as vehicle photos, price and mileage).
Inventory Analysis
Vehicle Age
Top Makes
Top Bodystyles
Domestic/Foreign
Luxury/Non-Luxury
Showing 1-20 of 38 Listings
Sort by:
$15,998
$16,134
GOOD DEAL
2013 Subaru BRZ Limited
- 42,993 Miles
- Listed 13 days ago
- Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
- $1,610 Below market value of $17,608
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2013 Subaru BRZ Limited for Sale
42,993 Miles
Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $15,998 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 4 Seats |
| VIN | JF1ZCAC16D1602982 |
| Location | Saint James, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, navigation, leather upholstery, alloy wheels, satellite radio |
| Mileage | 42,993 mi. |
| Transmission | Manual |
| Exterior Color | Blue |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 25 combined |
| Drivetrain | Rear-wheel drive |
$11,499
GOOD DEAL
2013 Subaru Impreza 2.0i Premium
- 30,401 Miles
- Listed 14 days ago
- Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
- $1,012 Below market value of $12,511
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2013 Subaru Impreza 2.0i Premium for Sale
30,401 Miles
Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $11,499 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF1GPAC61D2877158 |
| Location | Saint James, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, alloy wheels, voice recognition, power outlet |
| Mileage | 30,401 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Silver |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 30 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$29,998
GOOD DEAL
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
- 3,216 Miles
- Listed 24 days ago
- Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
- $2,444 Below market value of $32,442
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2025 Subaru Forester Premium for Sale
3,216 Miles
Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $29,998 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2SLDDC1SH522797 |
| Location | Saint James, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, sunroof |
| Mileage | 3,216 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Green |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$15,498
GOOD DEAL
2015 Honda Accord LX
- 48,251 Miles
- Listed 6 days ago
- Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
- $595 Below market value of $16,093
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2015 Honda Accord LX for Sale
48,251 Miles
Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $15,498 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 1HGCR2F38FA037284 |
| Location | Saint James, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 48,251 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | White |
| Interior Color | White |
| MPG | 31 combined |
| Drivetrain | Front-wheel drive |
$30,211
GOOD DEAL
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
- 3,460 Miles
- Listed 24 days ago
- Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
- $2,194 Below market value of $32,405
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2025 Subaru Forester Premium for Sale
3,460 Miles
Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $30,211 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2SLDBC7SH518868 |
| Location | Saint James, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, sunroof |
| Mileage | 3,460 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Gray |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$26,373
$26,802
GOOD DEAL
2023 Subaru Forester Sport
- 27,453 Miles
- Listed 31 days ago
- Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
- $2,491 Below market value of $28,864
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2023 Subaru Forester Sport for Sale
27,453 Miles
Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $26,373 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2SKAJC8PH527881 |
| Location | Saint James, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, sunroof |
| Mileage | 27,453 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | White |
| Interior Color | Gray |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$26,712
$27,422
GOOD DEAL
2023 Subaru Forester Premium
- 12,969 Miles
- Listed 25 days ago
- Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
- $1,621 Below market value of $28,333
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2023 Subaru Forester Premium for Sale
12,969 Miles
Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $26,712 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2SKAEC8PH443036 |
| Location | Saint James, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, sunroof |
| Mileage | 12,969 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Green |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$28,823
$29,412
GOOD DEAL
2022 Subaru Forester Limited
- 7,097 Miles
- Listed 37 days ago
- Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
- $1,151 Below market value of $29,974
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2022 Subaru Forester Limited for Sale
7,097 Miles
Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $28,823 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2SKAPC4NH503548 |
| Location | Saint James, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, leather upholstery, internet radio |
| Mileage | 7,097 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Brown |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$26,943
$27,272
GOOD DEAL
2022 Subaru Forester Sport
- 14,265 Miles
- Listed 41 days ago
- Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
- $1,029 Below market value of $27,972
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2022 Subaru Forester Sport for Sale
14,265 Miles
Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $26,943 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2SKAJC6NH510073 |
| Location | Saint James, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, sunroof |
| Mileage | 14,265 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Black |
| Interior Color | Gray |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$25,433
$25,632
GOOD DEAL
2023 Subaru Forester Premium
- 29,922 Miles
- Listed 35 days ago
- Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
- $1,698 Below market value of $27,131
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2023 Subaru Forester Premium for Sale
29,922 Miles
Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $25,433 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2SKAEC8PH420971 |
| Location | Saint James, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, sunroof |
| Mileage | 29,922 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Silver |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$26,903
$27,113
GOOD DEAL
2022 Subaru Ascent Premium 8-Passenger
- 35,204 Miles
- Listed 46 days ago
- Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
- $1,730 Below market value of $28,633
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2022 Subaru Ascent Premium 8-Passenger for Sale
35,204 Miles
Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $26,903 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 8 Seats |
| VIN | 4S4WMACD2N3470759 |
| Location | Saint James, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 35,204 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | White |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 23 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$21,322
$21,811
GOOD DEAL
2023 Subaru Impreza Premium
- 26,476 Miles
- Listed 30 days ago
- Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
- $1,005 Below market value of $22,327
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2023 Subaru Impreza Premium for Sale
26,476 Miles
Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $21,322 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 4S3GTAD61P3713590 |
| Location | Saint James, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 26,476 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Silver |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 31 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$24,312
$24,692
GOOD DEAL
2023 Subaru Crosstrek Sport
- 26,165 Miles
- Listed 16 days ago
- Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
- $1,042 Below market value of $25,354
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2023 Subaru Crosstrek Sport for Sale
26,165 Miles
Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $24,312 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2GTHSC5PH279423 |
| Location | Saint James, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 26,165 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Silver |
| Interior Color | Gray |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$21,872
$21,999
GOOD DEAL
2020 Honda HR-V EX
- 25,784 Miles
- Listed 37 days ago
- Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
- $604 Below market value of $22,476
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2020 Honda HR-V EX for Sale
25,784 Miles
Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $21,872 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | 3CZRU6H53LM701061 |
| Location | Saint James, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, sunroof |
| Mileage | 25,784 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Purple |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 28 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$22,624
$22,973
GOOD DEAL
2023 Subaru Crosstrek Sport
- 42,510 Miles
- Listed 48 days ago
- Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
- $1,784 Below market value of $24,408
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2023 Subaru Crosstrek Sport for Sale
42,510 Miles
Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $22,624 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2GTHSC1PH304009 |
| Location | Saint James, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 42,510 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Black |
| Interior Color | Gray |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$25,362
$25,512
GOOD DEAL
2023 Subaru Crosstrek Limited
- 26,996 Miles
- Listed 13 days ago
- Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
- $844 Below market value of $26,206
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2023 Subaru Crosstrek Limited for Sale
26,996 Miles
Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $25,362 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2GTHMCXP8329195 |
| Location | Saint James, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, leather upholstery, internet radio |
| Mileage | 26,996 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Gray |
| Interior Color | Gray |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$29,755
FAIR DEAL
2023 Subaru Forester Limited
- 14,189 Miles
- Listed 6 days ago
- Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
- $553 Above market value of $30,308
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2023 Subaru Forester Limited for Sale
14,189 Miles
Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $29,755 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2SKANC8PH400767 |
| Location | Saint James, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, leather upholstery, internet radio |
| Mileage | 14,189 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Gray |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 29 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$19,063
GOOD DEAL
2021 Subaru Crosstrek Premium
- 79,351 Miles
- Listed 6 days ago
- Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
- $423 Below market value of $19,486
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2021 Subaru Crosstrek Premium for Sale
79,351 Miles
Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $19,063 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | JF2GTAEC4M8375669 |
| Location | Saint James, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, internet radio, alloy wheels |
| Mileage | 79,351 mi. |
| Transmission | CVT |
| Exterior Color | Silver |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 30 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
$39,888
FAIR DEAL
2022 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 Limited RST
- 36,586 Miles
- Listed 6 days ago
- Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
- $307 Above market value of $39,581
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2022 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 Limited RST for Sale
36,586 Miles
Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $39,888 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 8-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 6 Seats |
| VIN | 1GCUYEED7NZ209998 |
| Location | Saint James, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, alloy wheels, satellite radio |
| Mileage | 36,586 mi. |
| Transmission | Automatic |
| Exterior Color | Gray |
| Interior Color | Black |
| MPG | 17 combined |
| Drivetrain | 4X4 |
$12,830
FAIR DEAL
2018 Hyundai Tucson SE
- 72,944 Miles
- Listed 13 days ago
- Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
- $244 Above market value of $13,074
- iSeeCars Dealer Score
Additional info close
Used 2018 Hyundai Tucson SE for Sale
72,944 Miles
Saint James, NY (0 mi away)
| Category | Used Cars |
| Price | $12,830 |
| For Sale By | dealer |
| iSeeCars Dealer Score | |
| Engine | 4-cylinder |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Seats | 5 Seats |
| VIN | KM8J2CA42JU651136 |
| Location | Saint James, NY - 0 mi. |
| Features | bluetooth, child safety, backup camera, alloy wheels, voice recognition |
| Mileage | 72,944 mi. |
| Transmission | Automatic |
| Exterior Color | White |
| Interior Color | Brown |
| MPG | 23 combined |
| Drivetrain | All-wheel drive |
Page 1 of 2
Other Nearby Dealers
Used Cars for Sale Insights
Find More Cars For Sale
Explore Models
Ford Fusion
Save $4,513 on 1,564 Deals
4,783 Listings from $1,600
4,783 Listings from $1,600
Honda Civic
Save $10,922 on 5,166 Deals
28,349 Listings from $1,500
28,349 Listings from $1,500
Hyundai Sonata
Save $5,955 on 2,247 Deals
12,833 Listings from $800
12,833 Listings from $800
GMC Sierra 1500
Save $14,441 on 6,875 Deals
38,158 Listings from $1,000
38,158 Listings from $1,000
Kia Optima
Save $4,855 on 971 Deals
2,554 Listings from $1,477
2,554 Listings from $1,477
Ford Super Duty F-250
Save $20,143 on 2,814 Deals
23,613 Listings from $3,999
23,613 Listings from $3,999
GMC Acadia
Save $9,602 on 2,742 Deals
11,672 Listings from $1,922
11,672 Listings from $1,922
Kia Soul
Save $4,965 on 1,707 Deals
9,230 Listings from $1,800
9,230 Listings from $1,800
Dodge Journey
Save $5,021 on 898 Deals
2,277 Listings from $1,900
2,277 Listings from $1,900
Chevrolet Silverado 2500hd
Save $13,987 on 2,006 Deals
17,801 Listings from $3,999
17,801 Listings from $3,999